He played a part for sure but nothing that makes him 100% a successful signing for £100m. He was definitely more successful than Philips though.So you don’t think he played any part in that success orf 3 titles and a treble and we were effectively a team of 10 . Pep must be even more of a genius than we thought. You think his contribution was equal to that of Carson and Phillips? Well it’s an opinion I suppose.