Album/Band battle No 1 Stone Roses vs, Definitely Maybe

[Cellarite]

The Stone Roses

 

[blueduff]

Oasis

 

[denislawsbackheel]

Stone Roses even though Ian Brown's voice is shit without a load of production.

 

[urban genie]

Stone Roses

 

[noely]

2 fave albums ever! So a tough one.

Deffo maybe shades it for me. Purely for the fact there's not a below par track on it and I was young enough to get into it at the time. But I'd say the Roses flows better as a complete album. GOD!. this is like choosing between Chips and Ale.

The better argument would be between the Drug fulled overblown failures - Second coming V Be here now

Second coming shits all over be here now Second Coming is a great album

 

[noely]

Stone Roses ......just

 

[s1ty m]

Both great albums. The Stone Roses gets my vote. Amazing band.

 

[SA96]

Oasis gets my vote.

Columbia is my favourite Oasis track.

 

[Ban-jani]

The stone roses.

 

[OB1]

Oasis.