All Time Top 1100 Albums (Aerosmith - Big Ones) P265

[FogBlueInSanFran]

He's added them together which is fair enough, I understood his thinking.
I also understand why you'd question it, the average is 3/10

Yes. The implication is side 1 is absolute shite (a 1/10) and side 2 is okay (a 5/10) then the overall is a mediocre 3, not a good enough but not great 6. :)

 

[mancity2012_eamo]

You’re all losing the plot.
I gave one point for the 1st side and five points for the second side.
There’s no averaging mentioned.

Out of the 1 point I’d say it’s charitably spread between the 1st and 5th track.
Most Anything You Want and
Are You Happy.
I never really played the first side much at all.

The second side though is an iconic classic. That’s what gets the marks.

I just figured my first post of three lines was self explanatory.

 

[RobMCFC]

You’re all losing the plot.
I gave one point for the 1st side and five points for the second side.
There’s no averaging mentioned.

Out of the 1 point I’d say it’s charitably spread between the 1st and 5th track.
Most Anything You Want and
Are You Happy.
I never really played the first side much at all.

The second side though is an iconic classic. That’s what gets the marks.

I just figured my first post of three lines was self explanatory.

You’ve taken a flyer here. This week’s album hasn’t been announced yet (although I am sure you are right - in fact I listened to it today).

 

[mancity2012_eamo]

You’ve taken a flyer here. This week’s album hasn’t been announced yet (although I am sure you are right - in fact I listened to it today).

And….
Are You Happy

 

[crublue1]

You’re all losing the plot.
I gave one point for the 1st side and five points for the second side.
There’s no averaging mentioned.

Out of the 1 point I’d say it’s charitably spread between the 1st and 5th track.
Most Anything You Want and
Are You Happy.
I never really played the first side much at all.

The second side though is an iconic classic. That’s what gets the marks.

I just figured my first post of three lines was self explanatory.

I got you straight away mate.
I'm just grateful it wasn't a double album, we'd be here all fucking night ;-)

 

[FogBlueInSanFran]

You’re all losing the plot.
I gave one point for the 1st side and five points for the second side.
There’s no averaging mentioned.

Out of the 1 point I’d say it’s charitably spread between the 1st and 5th track.
Most Anything You Want and
Are You Happy.
I never really played the first side much at all.

The second side though is an iconic classic. That’s what gets the marks.

I just figured my first post of three lines was self explanatory.

Fair enough.

 

[dronefromsector7G]

Fair enough.

It’s your fault, ****

 

[Bill Walker]

Its a muffin.

 

[FogBlueInSanFran]

It’s your fault, ****

It usually is.

 

[RobMCFC]

And….
Are You Happy

I couldn't possibly say until it's officially unveiled :)