Are Gundogan, Laporte, Mahrez and Palmer missed at all?

With Palmer what are we missing? he contributed so little but in saying that he could in time make us look fools in letting him leave.

Mahrez and Gundo were huge players for us, but personally think it was a good time for both to leave at the very top.
 
Last edited:
Keeper! said:
With Palmer what are we missing, he contributed so little but in saying that he could in time make us look fools in letting him leave.

Mahrez and Gundo were huge players for us, but personally think it was a good time for both to leave at the very top.
Click to expand...
Just don’t think he has what it takes to become an elite player. He’s got talent, no doubt about that, a lovely left foot but it’s not strong or quick enough.Maybe in time that might change.
 
citymad said:
Just don’t think he has what it takes to become an elite player. He’s got talent, no doubt about that, a lovely left foot but it’s not strong or quick enough.Maybe in time that might change.
Click to expand...
I would agree and Pep must have had similar thoughts but he's had a very solid start at Chelsea in very difficult circumstances.
 
Keeper! said:
With Palmer what are we missing? he contributed so little but in saying that he could in time make us look fools in letting him leave.

Mahrez and Gundo were huge players for us, but personally think it was a good time for both to leave at the very top.
Click to expand...
They were gonna leave sooner or later. I'm much happier they have left and we focus more on what they achieved and how beautifully they operated rather than hang on to them and only notice a decline. They were outstanding PL players and any team would miss their contribution, but we move on!
 
100% miss Gundo, huge player for us, tempo setter , feel with Gundo in team we would have won at Wolves and with him no longer being at club makes Rodri's suspension a bigger deal
 
Keeper! said:
With Palmer what are we missing? he contributed so little but in saying that he could in time make us look fools in letting him leave.

Mahrez and Gundo were huge players for us, but personally think it was a good time for both to leave at the very top.
Click to expand...
We're not missing Palmer because he was mainly a bench warmer. That said Many Chelsea fans are delighted with him and think he was a steal for 45M. Lol. I think we had them over right now but you never know.

And i agree about Gundo and Mahrez. Both are ageing and have achieved all they can for us so twas right to let them go before their legs go.
 
Too early to tell. We replaced Laporte with Gvardiol so I would say no on that one. Palmer didn't contribute a huge amount and Doku is already delivering to no.

Against Wolves and Newcastle I imagine we would have had better results with Gundo and Mahrez on the pitch personally. In games like that against Wolves, we would have had a lot more control and patience in possession and more goal threat from Gundo whilst Mahrez would have created something with his trickery I'm sure.

But overall we have coped incredibly well. Last night showed that we are a different team with the likes of Rodri and Bernardo in there, and Lewis did a much better job than Nunes and Kovacic last weekend.

But the injuries we have had meant we had to throw new players in early and it didn't work. Them being on the bench, with Ake too, was probably a kick up the arse from Pep as much as giving them a rest!
 
We’re missing a bit of experience so with Kev out long term I wouldn’t include Palmer, who I suspect is an outsider, mentally, and will end up never settling anywhere. He has been replaced already by the new signings and Oscar Bobb.

Any of the other three would be useful now, especially Gundo or Laporte. But it is what it is, I’m glad we parted with all 3 on good terms.
 
I think we miss Gundo, and concerning Cole, this season he would have done very well for us I think, but he obviously wasn’t committed to playing for City, shame he didn’t have a bond with the club, there was a clear pathway for minutes this season.
 
I don‘t think we’d be considering Gundo as a miss if we had Kev fit, and similar with Riyad that we’ve had a fair number out so he’d have definitely helped early season.

That said, bar the Carabao defeat which will prove to be a blessing anyway, then we are in fine fettle.
 
Keeper! said:
I would agree and Pep must have had similar thoughts but he's had a very solid start at Chelsea in very difficult circumstances.
Click to expand...

From what I’ve heard/ seen pep wanted him to stay, but he never keeps players who want to leave.

He’s been really good when he’s played for Chelsea so far. I think he would have been good for us and offered us goals and created chances
 
Gundo and Mahrez were big, BIG game players. Got us out the shit a lot of times.

But if they were still here then we don’t see Lewis at 8, or Alvarez playing regularly, or even Foden and I doubt we’d have seen Doku come in. Gvardiol was coming in regardless of Laporte, no chance the club were letting that chance pass by.

I think it was for the best just to give the squad a new feel, fresh legs and a different dimension to how we play. We won’t know if it’s for the best until the end of the season but I’m personally happy the club didn’t stand still after a treble.
 
Last edited:
Gundogan was a huge presence so we've got to find different ways of playing without him.

Laporte and Mahrez were both important at different times, but equally we needed to freshen up the squad so it was a good move for all concerned.

Mixed feelings about Palmer, because I still haven't see a definitive interview where either he or Pep admit that the only solution was for him to leave. Just a lot of people hearing, (or pretending to hear) third party gossip.
He wouldn't have started every game, but neither did Mahrez.
 
chaddblue said:
Gundo yes... the others no
Click to expand...
Trouble is whilst he’s one of the greatest players we’ve had, we have to recognise & plan for the fact that we can’t allow the team to become reliant on “aging” players.

Great as he is/was - it got to the stage that he didn’t turn up for every game (was often criticised for slowing down the game) - but when he did - WOW.

To avoid major “transition” problems we have to make tough decisions
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top