Atmosphere 2024/25

[its a Barm]

We should be celebrating it and singing about it every game. It’s one of the greatest achievements ever

it is and im very proud of it, but think all the banners is a bit cheesie, as fans we can sing our songs of glorious past achevements, anyway just my opinion.

 

[uwerosler28]

I'm not comfortable with theses 4 in a row banners there a bit scouce in my opinion, celebrate at the start of the season yes but not half way through, would prefer to just let our records speak for themselves.

Fucking hell, how long are you supposed to celebrate the greatest achievement in top flight football for the without it being "too much"

 

[M23 Citizen]

I’m utterly convinced that our 2-1 win at home to Liverpool in THAT game during the 2018/19 season was partly because of the atmosphere that night. It wasn’t so much the singing but the general hostility of the crowd towards their players. We never let up that might, save for about 2 minutes after they equalised. They were misplacing passes from the first minute and some of that was down to the fans getting on their backs.

I reckon singing is only about ¼ of what makes an atmosphere.

¾ is being involved in every kick of the ball: every pass is a ‘BALL!’, every tackle and interception comes with punch in the air and a ‘YYEESS!’, every dribble it’s a ‘GO OOON!’, every throw in won there’s applause, every corner you get on your feet clap and cheer the taker, every shot comes with a ‘OOOOOOH!’, every bad referee decision comes with a ‘FUCK OFF!’, every opposition miss gets a ‘AAAAAAAAAAHH, YOU SHIT ****’…

When most of the ground are all doing that, that’s what makes the best atmospheres.

Your example of the Liverpool 2019 2-1 win was the epitome of that. Same with the Kompany 2012 1-0 derby win. Both games actually had little singing (some at the start of the game, some around our goals, some at the end of the game, but a huge amount of the fan involvement in the games.

Those atmospheres are the best kind of atmospheres in football, better than the best examples of Ultras atmospheres. You can’t beat the best English proper up-for-it atmospheres.

 

[franksinatra]

I’m utterly convinced that our 2-1 win at home to Liverpool in THAT game during the 2018/19 season was partly because of the atmosphere that night. It wasn’t so much the singing but the general hostility of the crowd towards their players. We never let up that might, save for about 2 minutes after they equalised. They were misplacing passes from the first minute and some of that was down to the fans getting on their backs.

It definitely played a factor that night but like all great ‘British’ atmospheres it was very much triggered by the events on the pitch.

That game we were aggressive in the press and with the likes of Sane playing were always trying to get on the front foot. Still my favourite two years 2017-2019 watching the blues.

Although the fan base can certainly do more, it’s hard to jump out of your seat to a four yard square pass or slow drive forward.

 

[Originals]

I'm not comfortable with theses 4 in a row banners there a bit scouce in my opinion, celebrate at the start of the season yes but not half way through, would prefer to just let our records speak for themselves.

Obviously aimed at united cause they've never won 4 in a row

 

[Beaker]

I reckon singing is only about ¼ of what makes an atmosphere.

¾ is being involved in every kick of the ball: every pass is a ‘BALL!’, every tackle and interception comes with punch in the air and a ‘YYEESS!’, every dribble it’s a ‘GO OOON!’, every throw in won there’s applause, every corner you get on your feet clap and cheer the taker, every shot comes with a ‘OOOOOOH!’, every bad referee decision comes with a ‘FUCK OFF!’, every opposition miss gets a ‘AAAAAAAAAAHH, YOU SHIT ****’…

When most of the ground are all doing that, that’s what makes the best atmospheres.

Your example of the Liverpool 2019 2-1 win was the epitome of that. Same with the Kompany 2012 1-0 derby win. Both games actually had little singing (some at the start of the game, some around our goals, some at the end of the game, but a huge about of the fan involvement in the games.

Those atmospheres are the best kind of atmospheres in football, better than the best examples of Ultras atmospheres. You can’t beat the best English proper up-for-it atmospheres.

I agree with you 100% but that type of atmosphere is a response to what goes on on the pitch. I got the impression before kickoff on Sunday the crowd were up for giving it all of that, but the tepid game on the pitch put a stop to it. If City had got after United at any point, the crowd would have got stuck right in. Unfortunately they didn’t.

 

[give it to gordon]

I'm not comfortable with theses 4 in a row banners there a bit scouce in my opinion, celebrate at the start of the season yes but not half way through, would prefer to just let our records speak for themselves.

I don't like the big screen showing previous matches against our opponents as they warm up. I think rubbing their noses in it before the game just gets them more determined !

 

[EastMidlandsBlue]

I don't like the big screen showing previous matches against our opponents as they warm up. I think rubbing their noses in it before the game just gets them more determined !

I remember before away at Chelsea first game after we lost to them in Porto, jesus winner I believe. They were showing their top 5 Chelsea goals vs City.

Anyway they decided that the number 1 goal was the Havertz goal in the final, which was an absolutey shite goal! Made me chuckle a little, that felt like they were rubbing it in our faces!

 

[Didsbury Dave]

I reckon singing is only about ¼ of what makes an atmosphere.

¾ is being involved in every kick of the ball: every pass is a ‘BALL!’, every tackle and interception comes with punch in the air and a ‘YYEESS!’, every dribble it’s a ‘GO OOON!’, every throw in won there’s applause, every corner you get on your feet clap and cheer the taker, every shot comes with a ‘OOOOOOH!’, every bad referee decision comes with a ‘FUCK OFF!’, every opposition miss gets a ‘AAAAAAAAAAHH, YOU SHIT ****’…

When most of the ground are all doing that, that’s what makes the best atmospheres.

Your example of the Liverpool 2019 2-1 win was the epitome of that. Same with the Kompany 2012 1-0 derby win. Both games actually had little singing (some at the start of the game, some around our goals, some at the end of the game, but a huge about of the fan involvement in the games.

Those atmospheres are the best kind of atmospheres in football, better than the best examples of Ultras atmospheres. You can’t beat the best English proper up-for-it atmospheres.

I agree with this. It’s the roar of the crowd that makes an atmosphere that the players respond to. The only singing that makes a difference is that which goes around the stadium and fills the bowl. That’s why Pep gesticulates behind him when he wants more noise.

 

[Oldtraffordblue1]

It definitely played a factor that night but like all great ‘British’ atmospheres it was very much triggered by the events on the pitch.

That game we were aggressive in the press and with the likes of Sane playing were always trying to get on the front foot. Still my favourite two years 2017-2019 watching the blues.

Although the fan base can certainly do more, it’s hard to jump out of your seat to a four yard square pass or slow drive forward.

A scouse friend of mine was at ours for the CL game and said that atmosphere was up with any Anfield euro night and he's a "we've got the best ....... bla bla" Imagine if the non off side goal had stood what it would have gone to