A ballot really would never work.
We'd get the usual, oversubscribed for United, Liverpool Everton and any big games at the end of the season.
Soon as the midweek games and the Southampton or Palace away come round theyll be the same people (top level points who'd go) and the rest would end up on general sale like how the points system works now.
The points system surely shows who wants to go every game as they are top of the leader for going every game.
I disagree.
Firstly, the people at the top are there because they were at the right ages/positions at the right point in time. I know a fair few blues who went home and away in the 80s/90s, stopped going in the early 00s, and now struggle to get tickets because they missed the key years. I'm not saying those at the top don't deserve to be there, but we do have to offer opportunities to other (especially younger) fans for numerous reasons. I only started going week in, week out around 2012/2013 (I'm 28). I have managed to get 20k points, but an 18-year-old starting today has very little chance of getting there.
I think a ballot system that includes the following would work quite well:
- Weighted in favour of season card holders with more ticket points.
- Credits 'ticket points' to everyone who applies (regardless of whether they were successful or not).
- Tiered 'ticket points' depending on the opposition (Palace on a Monday night earns more points than United at 5:30 pm on a Sat).
- Allows fans to enter the ballot in groups.
- Only ticket points accumulated in the past 5 years are valid. Older points remain on the supporter's account for reference but don't increase the chance of qualifying for a ticket.
- Scraps platinum membership.
- Open and transparent figures released (number of supporters in ballot. % of fans with X points received tickets etc).
That would mean:
- fans at the top now would stay there (as long as they keep going)
- younger fans only have a 5-year period to catch up (rather than 22 years currently and growing - they might not get loads of tickets in that time, but by showing their intent and applying, they climb the ladder).
- fans with more ticket points are still rewarded with a much greater chance of getting away tickets.
- every City fan, no matter how old they are, starts in the same position of needing to build their points over 5 years rather than the continuously growing gap we have now.