nickamon
Well-Known Member
I like him and he’s played well all season but had a poor performance last night like the rest of the team.
I prefer Otamendi but only just! :)Not sold on him yet either. When he actually has to defend he’s looked sluggish and gets turned quite a lot by anyone with speed. Also infuriating how many times he lets the ball bounce in front of him instead of just going and meeting it with his head.
Much prefer Otamendi who was our best CB last season.
A bit like your post.I'm not sure what people are seeing with this guy he is bang average for me.
I prefer Otamendi but only just! :)
Fair point our system is very open so maybe we need a plan B for certain games.I also am mightily unconvinced by Laporte as a defender (particularly 1-on-1) - which is meant to be his primary role. Most likely why he has no caps for France. But at least he is young and could improve. Otamendi is a known quantity: brave and hard-working but rather slow and always at risk of a mistake or a bout of recklessness.
All that said, our system does expose our CBs, sometimes horribly, to fast counterattacks. Denayer had a pretty good game yesterday, but if playing for City, would likely have been skinned alive.
That's happening because DeBruyne is out and Gundogan is wank.Always a cause for concern when any of the defence feels the need to come into midfield and start playing the quarterback.
That's happening because DeBruyne is out and Gundogan is wank.
Every time I have seen him 1-on-1 against someone pacey or strong, he has looked suspect. Not overly impressed. Even in a 5-0 rout, saw it again yesterday.
We must be watching different games, I think he's hardly put a foot wrong all season and is one of the first names on the team sheet.Every time I have seen him 1-on-1 against someone pacey or strong, he has looked suspect. Not overly impressed. Even in a 5-0 rout, saw it again yesterday.
Both claims are not mutually exclusive.We must be watching different games, I think he's hardly put a foot wrong all season and is one of the first names on the team sheet.
Fair enough. Although I don't remember him getting caught out at all against Cardiff.Both claims are not mutually exclusive.