Balotelli or Hernandez?

[Ric]

what are you on about because of the transfer fee mario is the better player?

i will show you some facts

games goals
Javier Hernandez 25(19) 20

Mario Balotelli 21(7) 10

as much as i hate to say it taking everything into account Hernandez wins hands down

Didn't even realise Balotelli had played that many games. So having played only 4 more games, and a large portion of them being a sub, he has scored double Balotelli's tally so far. As you say, he wins hands down.

I think you're misreading those stats - Hernandez has made 44 appearances in total (including as a sub), Balotelli has made 28 in total.

 

[didactic]

Still people ignore the fact that United is a more rounded team. This whole question is silly rephrase it to how many goals would Balotelli score if he played for the scum.
Using transfer fees and and one season means nada Adebayor scored 25 goals in one season he cost the Arse peanuts does that make him better than Drogba, Torres, Ronaldo who he beat that season?.

Stupid, stupid thread just another witch hunt on Maro. Like I said before lets do a Iniesta v Silva thread. Iniesta was FREE to Barcelona. Silva cost us millions. Stop this stupid shit no wonder we called bitters cos we never happy with our own and always looking at those bastards and wanting theirs. Fuck Hernandez and count the number of assists Giggs, Valenica, Nani, Carrick and even shrek have compared to our players. I guess Balotelli is just supposed to score with no service and when we play with 2/3 holding midfielders every game. Are you guys crazy or what?

 

[Pigeonho]

Didn't even realise Balotelli had played that many games. So having played only 4 more games, and a large portion of them being a sub, he has scored double Balotelli's tally so far. As you say, he wins hands down.

I think you're misreading those stats - Hernandez has made 44 appearances in total (including as a sub), Balotelli has made 28 in total.

I right yeah i seem was reading it as 25 with 19 being as sub. Fair do's.
Either way though he has scored double Balotelli's.

 

[Kippax Street 1880]

Still people ignore the fact that United is a more rounded team. This whole question is silly rephrase it to how many goals would Balotelli score if he played for the scum.
Using transfer fees and and one season means nada Adebayor scored 25 goals in one season he cost the Arse peanuts does that make him better than Drogba, Torres, Ronaldo who he beat that season?.

Stupid, stupid thread just another witch hunt on Maro. Like I said before lets do a Iniesta v Silva thread. Iniesta was FREE to Barcelona. Silva cost us millions. Stop this stupid shit no wonder we called bitters cos we never happy with our own and always looking at those bastards and wanting theirs. Fuck Hernandez and count the number of assists Giggs, Valenica, Nani, Carrick and even shrek have compared to our players. I guess Balotelli is just supposed to score with no service and when we play with 2/3 holding midfielders every game. Are you guys crazy or what?

I think we're a better team than united I honestly do, but players like hernandez who run their bollocks off for 90 minutes are the reason their 1st and we're 4th !

 

[didactic]

I think we're a better team than united I honestly do, but players like hernandez who run their bollocks off for 90 minutes are the reason their 1st and we're 4th !

Im glad you "think" so but unfortunaly the numbers say different. Look up the assists for the scum players. They play a counter attack game where they ping the ball into the box and into their fowards with magnificent accuracy. And everyone saying Balotelli is lazy bollocks he runs his arse off but noone plays the ball to him when he is in the same place Hernandez scores from. Watch the games properly.

 

[Fame Monster]

Anyone who says Hernandez sounds suspiciously like a United fan, anyone who says Balotelli sounds suspiciously like he knows fuck all.

 

[Damocles]

Anyone who says Hernandez sounds suspiciously like a United fan, anyone who says Balotelli sounds suspiciously like he knows fuck all.

Glad you've found a way to feel superior to both sides.

 

[Kippax Street 1880]

I think we're a better team than united I honestly do, but players like hernandez who run their bollocks off for 90 minutes are the reason their 1st and we're 4th !

Im glad you "think" so but unfortunaly the numbers say different. Look up the assists for the scum players. They play a counter attack game where they ping the ball into the box and into their fowards with magnificent accuracy. And everyone saying Balotelli is lazy bollocks he runs his arse off but noone plays the ball to him when he is in the same place Hernandez scores from. Watch the games properly.

I know the style of play they play is better, But i feel player for player only Evra, Rooney and Van Der Sar would get in our team. Baconface is the only thing keeping United going as a force but people underestimate just how good a manager he is and the advantage he gives them, they could play their reserves every week, the likes of some wouldn't start for a team like villa or blackburn and still finish top four comfortably. They have that winning mentality we don't.

 

[didactic]

I know the style of play they play is better, But i feel player for player only Evra, Rooney and Van Der Sar would get in our team. Baconface is the only thing keeping United going as a force but people underestimate just how good a manager he is and the advantage he gives them, they could play their reserves every week, the likes of some wouldn't start for a team like villa or blackburn and still finish top four comfortably. They have that winning mentality we don't.

Exactly and they pass the ball better and therefore get more goals and assists. Strikers need service and playing lone striker in the premiership is suicide.

 

[Wiggum22]

Mouth breathers are out again.

Hernandez has nowhere NEAR the player of Balotelli. Not even a bit close. Firstly, he's entirely one footed; his left is purely for standing on. Secondly, his touch is shit. Thirdly, he can't pass short or long. Fourthly, his entire game is sitting on the edge of the line of defence (which when Balo does, he gets slagged off for been lazy) and hoping that somebody fucks up. Fifthly, he can't hold up a ball. Sixthly, he's got nowhere near the power or accuracy from long range. Seventhly, he's unable to beat a man. Eightly, he can't dribble with the ball. Ninthly, he's rubbish with his back to goal and tenthly, he's got no power.

Now, if you were to say that he's been more effective, I'd agree. If you were to say that he's been the better signing, I'd still agree (for now), but the idea that the Mexican equivalent of Michael Owen is a better all round player than the Italian version of Real Ronaldo, is utterly ridiculous.

I'm United and think Balotelli, if he gets rid ofthat chip on his shoulder and could be arsed, would become one of the Worlds best. The above 'assessment' of Javier Hernandez is mental.

1. The lad has scored 4 / 5 of his 20 goals with his left foot.
2. Most important 'touch' for a striker is the one that puts the ball into the net and he's pretty good at that.
3. He obviously can pass the football. A prerequisite of becoming a footballer.
4. He does often sit on the shoulder of the last defender but can never be accused of being lazy.
5. Often holds the ball up and brings other people into play. Surprising strong for his size.
6. Not really seen him hit a ball from distance so can't comment on that.
7. Regularly beats the goalkeeper and has the pace to beat defenders to through balls. The boy's a CentreForward not a tricky winger.
8. The boy's a Centre Forward not a tricky winger.
9. Isn't that the same as your ' he can't hold the ball up ' claim ? He scored a goal with his back ( and everything else )to the goal at Stoke.
10. No power where ? He has broke the net with headers and shots past goalkeepers all season. If you mean strength - see point 5.

Cue the "sad rag " on BM comments ...