balotelli or negredo?

A player that always gets sent off and rarely scores or a player that is clinical and so beastly that he is known as The Beast?

Difficult decision.
 
Mario reached his peak in the 6-1 and never really kicked on from that. he was viciously treated by the tabloids who painted him as stupid and half-crazed when, in fact, he is an educated and well-liked lad. He could never really shrug off his sheltered home background,brought up by a wealthy couple. This made him seek what he thought was street life-palling up with rappers and suchlike. (When he was interviewed by Noel Gallagher, he hadn't a clue about Manchester music).
Alf, by contrast,is a real streetwise guy-his dad's a taxi driver and Vallecas , where the Negredo family come from, is a very rundown suburb of Madrid.

Despite his zany image, Mario rarely produced moments of magic and his value lay more in functional things like being an infallible penalty-taker.
Alf,despite his nickname as ' The beast', is in fact a true football artist , as we have seen plenty of times already- his strike against Bayern,his supercool dummy , his dainty toe-trap and one-touch scooped pass to fuel Yaya's run against Spurs.
If you take Alf's strike on Sunday as a point of contrast, it's possible to imagine Mario executing a turn like that but I suspect that, if Dawson had pushed him in the face like he did with Alf, that he'd have gone down at once appealing the ref -instead of carrying on regardless, pivoting and smashing a rocket shot into the back of the net.
 
I don't think anyone can doubt his ability, on his day he can be brilliant but those days just don't happen regularly enough the rest of time he just dives, moans to the ref, petulant and its just like playing with 10 men. Ac Milan fans who were wanking over him last season are starting to find that out now. He'll never be a top level striker like Aguero, Suarez, Ibra et as he just doesnt have the desire imo
 
No contest negrado has done more in short stint at city than ball ever did. A couple of daft stunts,scoring penalties and the odd bit of skill showed when he could be arsed along with one good song do not make for a top footballer.BEast!!!
 
No contest I agree but give Balotelli is due he helped us to win a title, so I will remember him with fondness
 
I do think Balotelli has the potential to be great. but he's no where near it yet. Negredo is just fantastic though so there is no doubt he is by far the better player.
 
Skashion said:
balohatersgonnahate.jpg
Beautiful picture, sums up why our Mario was the player that always put the biggest smile on my face. But Negredo any day, love the Beast.
 
reminds me of my Niel McNabb or Messi thread<br /><br />-- Thu Nov 28, 2013 3:18 pm --<br /><br />
bluemc1 said:
reminds me of my Neil McNab or Messi thread

just for the spelling nuts
 
How the fuck did this get to 13 pages..... Some folk have a strange opinion on what makes a professional footballer and what his key attributes should be...."making you laugh" should really not be one of them!

Irony...now 14!
 
andy1971 said:
Mario had about four or five decent moments in two and a half years. That was it. Overall Negrado a far more effective player

He was only able to have 4 or 5 decent moments as he was banned the rest of the time.
Individually Mario but as said many times as a team player Negredo.
To quote the often used cliche 'which of the two would you want next to you in the trenches?'
 
Mad Eyed Screamer said:
andy1971 said:
Mario had about four or five decent moments in two and a half years. That was it. Overall Negrado a far more effective player

He was only able to have 4 or 5 decent moments as he was banned the rest of the time.
Individually Mario but as said many times as a team player Negredo.
To quote the often used cliche 'which of the two would you want next to you in the trenches?'

think a lot of people underestimating Negredos skill when comparing him to Mario, in all his time at City did we see Mario score a more skilful goal than Negredos V Spurs ? his lob over his head and volley attempt ? his dummy v West Ham ? some of his layoffs for some of the goals we have scored and some we should have scored have been lovely and he even past to feet with his head twice last night, if Mario had done all these things people would be saying he is worth 70 million and one of the best in the world
still wish we would have paid twice as much for Andy Carroll though :)
 
Dzekolol said:
Balotelli won us The FA Cup and Premier league title.

Negredo .............................................................................?

I love Negredo but Balo is a winner

LOL your a card
 
Dzekolol said:
Balotelli won us The FA Cup and Premier league title.

Negredo .............................................................................?

I love Negredo but Balo is a winner
Balo has been part of winning teams.

His contribution to those teams has always been minimal.
 
Negrado in a heartbeat. Mario is as mad as a box of frogs but is destined to waste his talent. I thought it was his dream move to AC MIlan and now what 6 months later he is turning up late for training - The boy's a fool or maybe he's just fooling everyone else?
 
gordondaviesmoustache said:
BOMBER7967 said:
How the fuck did this get to 13 pages..... Some folk have a strange opinion on what makes a professional footballer and what his key attributes should be...."making you laugh" should really not be one of them!
Jason Manford's still got a shot of being a professional footballer then.
Read Bomber's post again; he said ''making you laugh''. That rules out Jason!
 
jimharri said:
gordondaviesmoustache said:
BOMBER7967 said:
How the fuck did this get to 13 pages..... Some folk have a strange opinion on what makes a professional footballer and what his key attributes should be...."making you laugh" should really not be one of them!
Jason Manford's still got a shot of being a professional footballer then.
Read Bomber's post again; he said ''making you laugh''. That rules out Jason!
The word "not" in his post seems to have escaped you, jim :-)
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top