I cannot consider that somebody can have a worthwhile opinion on something that they have 0 data or experience on, yes.
This will never change, on any topic at all, because the alternative is stupid dribble that by its very nature is uninformed
I again apologize that point out that having an opinion on something you literally hold no data at all on has offended you so previously. I'll pre-warn that this won't stop me pointing it out if you were to make the same mistake in the future.
Damocles do you genuinely believe that someone who doesn't have data of experience of racism or homophobia should have no opinion? Or does experience in your eyes allow for second hand experience so seeing it or its results allows for an opinion. If the latter fair enough but then surely that would cover the validity of most people's opinions?
you seem to have a very upper left quartile analytical mind but as a scientist you seem to not accept the validity of people who are driven by their emotion or who are big picture or who have a mind different to the way your own functions. I am making assumptions based on your comments.
There is no data available for most
of life (though I am sure one day scientists will give us algorithms to explain everything). Much of what people feel comes from deep within and also is shaped from first and second hand experience.
What people get frustrated about is people legalistically picking on small details or small mistakes and invalidating opinion on "technicalities" that to me is what politicians do today, pivot the discussion, pick on something almost irellevant and try to doscredit individuals not arguments.
That's the whole gist of this post too many play the man and not the ball, too many think it's a one v one argument that they need to win not a discussion or argument (that has no victor)
Everybody me included needs to be a bit less pompous, a bit less bothered about the person they are debating with and a bit more focused on what the real discussions are on not irellevant point scoring .
Also Damocles most of this post is aimed at everyone not you, where only the first bit is specific to my quote of yours the rest more general