Bill Walker
Well-Known Member
Re: Battle of the Bands - Echo & Bunnymen v Small Faces page 52
Small Faces by a mile :)
Small Faces by a mile :)
danburge82 said:The Beach Boys were good, but they never made a song as good as "Whole Lotta Love" (hardly anyone ever has!).
So Led Zeppelin wins for me.
danburge82 said:However, I don't like the Bee Gees at all. They're just a cheesy pop and disco act.
Jim Beam said:This whole thread is fucking pointless, you might as well pose the question who's better S Club 7 or The Pixies?
What it does do though is allow fantasists to post fabricated accounts of their hedonistic youth.
I think danburge is getting his beach boys mixed up with his bee gees as disco/cheesy pop weren't around at the time of the beach boysRightoldcharmer said:danburge82 said:The Beach Boys were good, but they never made a song as good as "Whole Lotta Love" (hardly anyone ever has!).
So Led Zeppelin wins for me.
That's entirely subjective,and one that I'd never agree with.I don't even think it was the best song on that second album.
Zeppelin never created anything anywhere near as fresh,original and ground breaking as Good Vibrations.Brian Wilson was far,far more important in the development of popular music than Led Zeppelin,who were famous plagiarists,ever were.
danburge82 said:However, I don't like the Bee Gees at all. They're just a cheesy pop and disco act.
Now this is just a ridiculous post.A cheesy disco act? You're going to pigeonhole a group with one of the deepest,most varied songwriting catalogues based on a movie soundtrack? How much of their music have you actually listened to?
Jim Beam said:This whole thread is fucking pointless, you might as well pose the question who's better S Club 7 or The Pixies?
What it does do though is allow fantasists to post fabricated accounts of their hedonistic youth.
Jim Beam said:This whole thread is fucking pointless, you might as well pose the question who's better S Club 7 or The Pixies?
What it does do though is allow fantasists to post fabricated accounts of their hedonistic youth.