Bernardo Silva

Status
Not open for further replies.
I do want us to sign Bernardo Silva but other areas need more attention. There are plenty of players who carved themselves a very good career despite being one footed so that shouldn't be a major problem for Silva either.
 
Wonderfull game for him tonight, one more time, after an awesome entry vs Marseille in cup.. Will be tough for Monaco to keep him. He's too big for the club right now. I hope he will choose M.City or Barcelona over MU or Chelsea. Here are some highlights :









 
Silva and Mpabbe are the only Monaco players I think we should consider. The others a very good, but these 2 are exceptional.
 
Dax777 said:
Silva and Mpabbe are the only Monaco players I think we should consider. The others a very good, but these 2 are exceptional.
Click to expand...

As much as I rate Bernardo Silva, I would rather concentrate on Isco given that he would come cheaper with him having one year left on his contract in the summer, which means we can then prioritise our budget more on improving the defence, such as a new centre half, new full backs and a dynamite striker in Mbappe.
 
Dax777 said:
Silva and Mpabbe are the only Monaco players I think we should consider. The others a very good, but these 2 are exceptional.
Click to expand...

Maybe Bakayoko, Fabinho and mendy can have a great carrer too.
But these two got some ballon d'or potentials.

Tho, on City side, i agree with citizens_1976. Isco should cost half the price of silva, and isn't that much under Silva.
 
Afrenchguy said:
Maybe Bakayoko, Fabinho and mendy can have a great carrer too.
But these two got some ballon d'or potentials.

Tho, on City side, i agree with citizens_1976. Isco should cost half the price of silva, and isn't that much under Silva.
Click to expand...

What do you think about Lemar? And his potential?
 
citizens_1976 said:
As much as I rate Bernardo Silva, I would rather concentrate on Isco given that he would come cheaper with him having one year left on his contract in the summer, which means we can then prioritise our budget more on improving the defence, such as a new centre half, new full backs and a dynamite striker in Mbappe.
Click to expand...
Oh I agree with you. Was just pointing out that he and Mbappe were the 2 exceptional talents on the squad. Of take Isco for half the price.
 
BlueCityfan said:
What do you think about Lemar? And his potential?
Click to expand...

Technically, he's maybe as much as good as silva, even maybe a bit better.
But he need to improove his football IQ, and defensive skills. As a guy, he's a worker, quiet, almost never doing ITW, not going out, etc etc..

I forgot him in my post, cause he is out of breath since a good month now, but he can also have a great great carreer. But I don't see him mooving this summer to a top club. Stayin at Monaco, or maybe Atletico, something like that.

He also have an awesome chemistery with Mendy, but seems a bit under his level when Sidibe or Raggi play as Left back.

Tho, he once played as Left Back 60 minutes after Mendy's red card vs Lyon (don't judge him on that, Tolisso is an asshole) and have been stunish. He just need to feel confident on his side i think, wich he's not with Sidibe or Raggi behind him.
 
Afrenchguy said:
Technically, he's maybe as much as good as silva, even maybe a bit better.
But he need to improove his football IQ, and defensive skills. As a guy, he's a worker, quiet, almost never doing ITW, not going out, etc etc..

I forgot him in my post, cause he is out of breath since a good month now, but he can also have a great great carreer. But I don't see him mooving this summer to a top club. Stayin at Monaco, or maybe Atletico, something like that.

He also have an awesome chemistery with Mendy, but seems a bit under his level when Sidibe or Raggi play as Left back.

Tho, he once played as Left Back 60 minutes after Mendy's red card vs Lyon (don't judge him on that, Tolisso is an asshole) and have been stunish. He just need to feel confident on his side i think, wich he's not with Sidibe or Raggi behind him.
Click to expand...
Im interested in your opinion on Mendy to me he looks one of the best leftbacks in Europe and would suit us down to the ground would he want to move to England?
 
Bill said:
he's the closest thing to Dave I've seen.
Click to expand...

Except Dave has played at the highest level for ten years, winning titles for both club and country, whilst also coping with the slog of England.

We've seemingly signed plenty players in the past who looked world-beaters, only for us to discover they can't cut it at a club where you are expected to deliver every week.

Bernado Silva has excellent technical capacity, but he's not even comparable to Isco, who has existed at a much higher level in Spain at the biggest club in the world.

I remember when Gourcuff and Ben Arfa were being heralded from the rooftops in such a shit league.

I would rather save £50m and spend it on two full-backs and sign Isco.
 
tolmie's hairdoo said:
Except Dave has played at the highest level for ten years, winning titles for both club and country, whilst also coping with the slog of England.

We've seemingly signed plenty players in the past who looked world-beaters, only for us to discover they can't cut it at a club where you are expected to deliver every week.

Bernado Silva has excellent technical capacity, but he's not even comparable to Isco, who has existed at a much higher level in Spain at the biggest club in the world.

I remember when Gourcuff and Ben Arfa were being heralded from the rooftops in such a shit league.

I would rather save £50m and spend it on two full-backs and sign Isco.
Click to expand...
Agreed
 
tolmie's hairdoo said:
Except Dave has played at the highest level for ten years, winning titles for both club and country, whilst also coping with the slog of England.

We've seemingly signed plenty players in the past who looked world-beaters, only for us to discover they can't cut it at a club where you are expected to deliver every week.

Bernado Silva has excellent technical capacity, but he's not even comparable to Isco, who has existed at a much higher level in Spain at the biggest club in the world.

I remember when Gourcuff and Ben Arfa were being heralded from the rooftops in such a shit league.

I would rather save £50m and spend it on two full-backs and sign Isco.
Click to expand...

I like the look of Silva, B but I would take Isco ahead of him.
 
tolmie's hairdoo said:
Except Dave has played at the highest level for ten years, winning titles for both club and country, whilst also coping with the slog of England.

We've seemingly signed plenty players in the past who looked world-beaters, only for us to discover they can't cut it at a club where you are expected to deliver every week.

Bernado Silva has excellent technical capacity, but he's not even comparable to Isco, who has existed at a much higher level in Spain at the biggest club in the world.

I remember when Gourcuff and Ben Arfa were being heralded from the rooftops in such a shit league.

I would rather save £50m and spend it on two full-backs and sign Isco.
Click to expand...

That's why Isco is likely to leave Madrid, yet you cite it as a reason to target him instead of Silva.

You also underestimate Silva, could be one of the very best within a couple of years.
 
panne said:
That's why Isco is likely to leave Madrid, yet you cite it as a reason to target him instead of Silva.

You also underestimate Silva, could be one of the very best within a couple of years.
Click to expand...

I'd argue Isco is likely to leave Madrid because he hasn't been able to get enough regular game time, not because he isn't good enough, but because he has better players ahead of him.

And certainly ones that Bernardo Silva would not get in ahead of either, at the present time.

Curse of Real Madrid for Isco, who can hardly be blamed at wanting to sign for them when they came knocking.

He could always pull those two Champions League medals out of his back pocket.

Our own David Silva would have struggled to get a game every week at Madrid, such is their stocked roster.

It's not my money, I would take both B Silva and Isco, simply because we will be losing Dave in the next couple years, Nasri won't be back and there is no guarantee that Gundogan will be able to remain fit.

For the price of Pogba, we'd get both.
 
tolmie's hairdoo said:
I'd argue Isco is likely to leave Madrid because he hasn't been able to get enough regular game time, not because he isn't good enough, but because he has better players ahead of him.

And certainly ones that Bernardo Silva would not get in ahead of either, at the present time.

Curse of Real Madrid for Isco, who can hardly be blamed at wanting to sign for them when they came knocking.

He could always pull those two Champions League medals out of his back pocket.

Our own David Silva would have struggled to get a game every week at Madrid, such is their stocked roster.

It's not my money, I would take both B Silva and Isco, simply because we will be losing Dave in the next couple years, Nasri won't be back and there is no guarantee that Gundogan will be able to remain fit.

For the price of Pogba, we'd get both.
Click to expand...
I like where your head is at :-)
 
Out of all Monaco's players, he'd be my number one signing, followed by Mendy. Not often do you see someone outplay Dave at his own game
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top