Bernardo Silva

Status
Not open for further replies.
The writing's on the wall. June 2023 is the hottest since records began & three times last month, the hottest June daily global temperature records were beaten & it's set to get even hotter in the following years. \0/

It was 2 degrees hotter when the Roman empire ruled the UK, the earth goes through natural cycles of heating and cooling and our star is entering a solar maximum so it's going to get hotter for a bit, then cool again
 
It was 2 degrees hotter when the Roman empire ruled the UK, the earth goes through natural cycles of heating and cooling and our star is entering a solar maximum so it's going to get hotter for a bit, then cool again
Who was recording the temperature in Roman times?
 
£45m is daft, way too low. Mason Mount is £60m, Declan Rice £105m, only 1 year in their contracts. Bernardo has 2, is way better than both and only £45m? Nah
Rice and Mount are both 5 years younger than Bernardo. Both Mount and Rice were inter Premier League transfers. Only PL clubs plus PSG, Barcelona and Real Madrid can pay big fees. Given we all know you would never sell Bernardo to a domestic rival, PSG know there is no one to bid against given Real Madrid and Barcelona are not interested.

If Chelsea sold Haavertz to Bayern, it would have been for around 40m. But they were willing to sell to a domestic rival so they got a full fee, likewise with Mount. You can say the same thing last year with Jesus and Sterling.

The conditions are just not right for a sale of 60-80m for Bernardo. Everything points to a sale of less than 50m, either that or you keep him for another season.
 
Rice and Mount are both 5 years younger than Bernardo. Both Mount and Rice were inter Premier League transfers. Only PL clubs plus PSG, Barcelona and Real Madrid can pay big fees. Given we all know you would never sell Bernardo to a domestic rival, PSG know there is no one to bid against given Real Madrid and Barcelona are not interested.

If Chelsea sold Haavertz to Bayern, it would have been for around 40m. But they were willing to sell to a domestic rival so they got a full fee, likewise with Mount. You can say the same thing last year with Jesus and Sterling.

The conditions are just not right for a sale of 60-80m for Bernardo. Everything points to a sale of less than 50m, either that or you keep him for another season.
I offer you Kovacic… We paid £25m! I’ll also point out Barça have been promising Bernardo for the last 3 windows that he’s their no1 priority, yet every window they fuck him about! It’s not about nobody being able to pay and more about clubs know City will bend over on sales to ship them off the wage bill. PSG are struggling with balancing their books, they are trying it on and I suspect if he goes there that it’ll be “undisclosed’ for 12 months until their/our accounts are released.
Some Man City fans think Jesus was sold too cheaply, some think we had your pants down but either way that’s the same with any transfer at any club. Rice/Mount maybe younger by 5 years but they’ll never be Bernardo Silva, they are not really fit enough to lace his boots and never will be. You cannot therefore compare their fee’s on age and position alone.
I do agree domestic sales can and sometimes do offer a premium on the valuation but I’d not say it’s a standard, my original first four words back that up.
City don’t have to sell him either, he has 2 yrs left on his contract and despite wanting to leave a few seasons now, he’s a professional and has always given 100% effort. I’d be more than happy to keep him, I’d personally not sell him for £100m as he’s that valuable to us in terms of what he brings to the table, but £80m is cheap and fair in reality.
I also don’t agree the conditions are not right to demand a true valuation, with the Saudi’s now sniffing around players and wanting top draw players in their league, now is the perfect time to demand a high amount for one of our prize assets. It’s simple business, if clubs want him they pay up, if not he can continue 2 more years and leave for free. Bernardo to the French league or Saudi Arabia draws bums on seats and would be a marque signing for either league.
 
Bernardo is a brilliant footballer, no doubt. An energizer bunny of an engine.

Alas, he apparently stayed and was quiet last season in the knowledge that he could leave this season.
The whole world knows he wants out.
He has zero pace.
He can go for nothing soon.
45M is a “respectful” figure that balances affordability with his desire to leave and his remaining contract length.

1) What did we pay for him?
2) Did we get the best years of his career?
3) What are we willing to sell him for?
4) What was the net cost for those years of brilliance?
This is laughable. How anyone can consider selling a player of his talents and age for anything less than 80m needs to wobble their head

He cost City 45m and wasn't in his prime, now he is, you'd sell him for that

pace is irrelevant in his case. His ball retention and passing abilities mean more

I'd rather keep him for the reminder of his contract and win more trophies, than let him go for 45m
 
What we paid for him is not all that material in deciding what his current value is. I mean players that cost nothing are going for hundreds of millions euros or close to that. Bernardo may not have pace but when you look at what he brings to teams, you cannot help but appreciate his value. He is not a winger so pace is not a deal breaker to anyone that might be interested. Right from his days at Monaco where he and his lads had a great UCL showing he’s gone from strength to strength. Will £45m give you any reasonable value in the current market for an attacking midfielder? Now consider that he was a vital cog in the wheel of a team that just won the treble, shouldn’t that strengthen our hands in the negotiations rather than weaken it?
I believe you have completely missed the point.
 
£45m is daft, way too low. Mason Mount is £60m, Declan Rice £105m, only 1 year in their contracts. Bernardo has 2, is way better than both and only £45m? Nah
Perhaps it was part of an agreement the club made with him to get him to stay?

Age is also a factor.

All of that said, none of us have any idea of the reason for the value…or even if it’s a correct valuation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.