best summer signin robinho or swp?

[Cambridgeblue]

Name - Goals

Robinho - 15
Stephen Ireland - 13
Shaun Wright-Phillips - 8
Elano - 8
Felipe Caicedo - 7
Craig Bellamy - 4
Daniel Sturridge - 4
Jo - 3

Says it all really...

 

[mcfc_nick]

Robbie by far out of the two! if it was the best summer signing altogether it has to be ben haim!

 

[cleavers]

Those blues who are still gooey eyed about SWP should watch the football matches we play, he barely merits a first team spot when fit now, sorry but if we want top 4 he won't be starting, whereas Robinho will every time.

 

[southamptonblue]

preferred the old SWP tbh.

agreed, hughes said he's come back a better player, i disagree, he was better before he left.

More like he LOOKED better before he left,whilst playing in a crap side! ........He now looks slightly better than he did at Chelsea,as he's in a slightly worse side....IMO will never play regularly for a top 4 side.

Comparing SWP to Robinho.......bit daft if you ask me ;)

 

[blue1969]

Robbie

 

[bizzbo]

i dont think shauns been properly fit since november

 

[lostmyhouseski]

robby every time..and sadly swp will be losing his pace in the not too distant future. will have to start going to the gym with big phil and micah after that

 

[Tell The King]

Robinho. I'd say he's been the best summer signing full stop to be honest.

 

[Sheikh n Bake]

SWP's not been all that great IMO. Robbie's been inconsistent but his goals have been important.

 

[Grand Master Ram Rod]

SWP for me, but Robbie has done well.