Cavan Sullivan

You think so? Phil wasn’t playing first team football at his age and dictating tempo. MLS probably sits somewhere between the PL and Championship.
Championship on aggregate is a much higher standard than the MLS. The MLS has some standout older players.

Tempo, maturity, physicality, it’s absolutely bobbins. Phil at 13 could have ran the MLS.
 
Championship on aggregate is a much higher standard than the MLS. The MLS has some standout older players.

Tempo, maturity, physicality, it’s absolutely bobbins. Phil at 13 could have ran the MLS.
That’s probably debatable given that MLS was sixth in the World Cup for player representation. It’s come a long way. Watched a couple games the other day and was pleasantly surprised.
 
That’s probably debatable given that MLS was sixth in the World Cup for player representation. It’s come a long way. Watched a couple games the other day and was pleasantly surprised.
How many of those players were 30+ European stars of yesteryear. Tells you everything you need to know that the USA’s squad only had 7 MLS players or something, with barely any playing.

Edit: there was 9 Canada MLS players, 8 USA.

MLS players in World Cup: 45, Championshio: 37.

I think the auto qualification of those two nations accounts for difference in numbers imo.
 
How many of those players were 30+ European stars of yesteryear. Tells you everything you need to know that the USA’s squad only had 7 MLS players or something, with barely any playing.

Edit: there was 9 Canada MLS players, 8 USA.

MLS players in World Cup: 45, Championshio: 37.

I think the auto qualification of those two nations accounts for difference in numbers imo.

Your argument is a joke, right? Even without automatic qualification, the 48-team expansion made the US and Canada absolute locks. Honestly, even under the old rules, the US qualifies almost every single time, and Canada literally won the entire CONCACAF qualifying group in the previous World Cup cycle. They were making the tournament either way, so using their host status to write off the MLS numbers is completely meaningless.

MLS had better player representation than the Championship in the World Cup. End of story.
 
Your argument is a joke, right? Even without automatic qualification, the 48-team expansion made the US and Canada absolute locks. Honestly, even under the old rules, the US qualifies almost every single time, and Canada literally won the entire CONCACAF qualifying group in the previous World Cup cycle. They were making the tournament either way, so using their host status to write off the MLS numbers is completely meaningless.

MLS had better player representation than the Championship in the World Cup. End of story.
Okay mate, agree to disagree on the original point though.
 
This is the first time I’ve logged-in to BM in many years, and I came just to say this kid looks like the absolute business for 16. Watched him for the first time today. Our club absolutely knows what it’s doing.
I’ve been watching him play on Philadelphia, he’s absolutely electric. Hopefully he will put on some weight and get a bit stronger by the time he turns 18.
 
Okay mate, agree to disagree on the original point though.


Championship is the 9th highest ranked league, MLS is 18th just below the Ecuadorean, Croatian and Norwegian.
 

Championship is the 9th highest ranked league, MLS is 18th just below the Ecuadorean, Croatian and Norwegian.

LMAOOOOO. Imagine citing Opta’s power rankings like they’re holy scripture. That algorithm is complete bullshit and anyone who actually follows football analytics knows it.

Opta calculates league strength by taking the raw mathematical average of every single team in a division. That completely breaks when you compare small 10-to-12 team leagues like Croatia, Norway, or Ecuador against a massive 30-team league like MLS. Smaller leagues don't have a long tail of bottom-dwellers dragging down their mean score, so two decent teams at the top artificially inflate the entire league's rank.

On top of that, Opta’s cross-continental connections are notoriously broken because non-European clubs almost never play European clubs in official matches, making inter-confederation mathematical links complete guesswork. Even Opta admits the model has to fill in the gaps through league, country and continental ratings. It even says that when an English club plays a Brazilian club, the result updates the teams and the continents, but not the league ratings. Yet you are treating the final list as if MLS, Norway, Croatia and Ecuador all played enough games against each other to establish an exact order.

Opta’s model is the same broken algorithm that’s previously ranked Leipzig ahead of Real Madrid.

Meanwhile, MLS had 45 active players at the 2026 World Cup, more than any league in the Western Hemisphere and second-most outside Europe’s top five. Twenty-two MLS clubs had at least one player there, more than any other domestic league in the world.

That is actual evidence of league-wide depth.

A model that puts MLS behind Ecuador while admitting that it barely has any direct evidence connecting those leagues is a joke and is incomplete data dressed up as an proper answer.

Real-world proof shows MLS can be argued at sixth. Not some data science intern’s shitty, fallacious (and arbitrary) algorithm.
 
Last edited:
Cavan starts for Philadelphia Union tonight - kickoff in less than an hour at 12:30 AM UK time! You can watch on streamed . pk after clicking two ads.
Philadelphia needs to do something about their sponsors, seeing the word “bimbo” across the chests of the Union players is rough.
 
LMAOOOOO. Imagine citing Opta’s power rankings like they’re holy scripture. That algorithm is complete bullshit and anyone who actually follows football analytics knows it.

Opta calculates league strength by taking the raw mathematical average of every single team in a division. That completely breaks when you compare small 10-to-12 team leagues like Croatia, Norway, or Ecuador against a massive 30-team league like MLS. Smaller leagues don't have a long tail of bottom-dwellers dragging down their mean score, so two decent teams at the top artificially inflate the entire league's rank.

On top of that, Opta’s cross-continental connections are notoriously broken because non-European clubs almost never play European clubs in official matches, making inter-confederation mathematical links complete guesswork. Even Opta admits the model has to fill in the gaps through league, country and continental ratings. It even says that when an English club plays a Brazilian club, the result updates the teams and the continents, but not the league ratings. Yet you are treating the final list as if MLS, Norway, Croatia and Ecuador all played enough games against each other to establish an exact order.

Opta’s model is the same broken algorithm that’s previously ranked Leipzig ahead of Real Madrid.

Meanwhile, MLS had 45 active players at the 2026 World Cup, more than any league in the Western Hemisphere and second-most outside Europe’s top five. Twenty-two MLS clubs had at least one player there, more than any other domestic league in the world.

That is actual evidence of league-wide depth.

A model that puts MLS behind Ecuador while admitting that it barely has any direct evidence connecting those leagues is a joke and is incomplete data dressed up as an proper answer.

Real-world proof shows MLS can be argued at sixth. Not some data science intern’s shitty, fallacious (and arbitrary) algorithm.

On average championship players get paid twice as much as MLS with the median of £10k versus £5k. If that’s not enough Bradley Wright Phillips also ran in the championship broke records in the MLS. The idea that you base the strength of the MLS having more players in the World Cup is ridiculous considering most championship players come from England & there’s only 24 places & the likes of Foden & Palmer didn’t even get selected.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top