Celtic Thread - 2023/24

Status
Not open for further replies.
All contact isn't a penalty. Especially when the player slows down to initiate the contact and then does a horrendous dive. If his fall had been more believable he may have got it.

I didn't see the handball
Handball is a bit meh. It’s a driven cross where player is sliding into block and hits his arm.You’d shout for it but some you get some you don’t.

All four can be genuinely argued either way.

Funny the Jambo poster has such a short memory. League Cup semi final a Hearts player given second yellow for blatant dive. Replay shows the Rangers defender has the barest of touch on his heel and referee overturns his original decision and awards Hearts the penalty!

Now even funnier is the referee who overturned his original decision was …… Nick Walsh!!!

Now if you include the handball in Old Firm that’s 6 debatable penalties in a few games and five go in Celtics favour and in the game not involving his beloved Celtic he gives the decision against Rangers.

Nope. Nothing to see here. Perfectly normal sequence of events. Move on!
 
Handball is a bit meh. It’s a driven cross where player is sliding into block and hits his arm.You’d shout for it but some you get some you don’t.

All four can be genuinely argued either way.

Funny the Jambo poster has such a short memory. League Cup semi final a Hearts player given second yellow for blatant dive. Replay shows the Rangers defender has the barest of touch on his heel and referee overturns his original decision and awards Hearts the penalty!

Now even funnier is the referee who overturned his original decision was …… Nick Walsh!!!

Now if you include the handball in Old Firm that’s 6 debatable penalties in a few games and five go in Celtics favour and in the game not involving his beloved Celtic he gives the decision against Rangers.

Nope. Nothing to see here. Perfectly normal sequence of events. Move on!
I think the first Celtic penalty could go either way to be honest. You don't see the given much, but that doesn't mean it wasn't a foul for dangerous play. If its outside the box its probably a free, but i can also see the argument that its on the soft side.
Kyogo's is pretty much a clear penalty, despite getting the shot away he's fouled after, these are usually always given nowadays.
Boyles was a dive.

From what I saw of the game Celtic were brutal and Hibs had the better chances.
Kuhn looks a flop, which isn't surprising given his career to date.
 
Handball is a bit meh. It’s a driven cross where player is sliding into block and hits his arm.You’d shout for it but some you get some you don’t.

All four can be genuinely argued either way.

Funny the Jambo poster has such a short memory. League Cup semi final a Hearts player given second yellow for blatant dive. Replay shows the Rangers defender has the barest of touch on his heel and referee overturns his original decision and awards Hearts the penalty!

Now even funnier is the referee who overturned his original decision was …… Nick Walsh!!!

Now if you include the handball in Old Firm that’s 6 debatable penalties in a few games and five go in Celtics favour and in the game not involving his beloved Celtic he gives the decision against Rangers.

Nope. Nothing to see here. Perfectly normal sequence of events. Move on!
Lol.
 
Both were penalties, we were fucking awful though. Thankfully Rangers are also shit. We don’t start turning up though and we are doomed.
 
Just seen the Kyogo dive against Hearts from earlier in the season. Shocker but penalty awarded

Go on. Humour me.

Guess who the referee was…..,

That’s right. Nick Walsh!
 
Both were penalties, we were fucking awful though. Thankfully Rangers are also shit. We don’t start turning up though and we are doomed.
Big game this weekend for Brendan.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.