City launch legal action against the Premier League | City win APT case (pg901)

[Churchlawtonblue]

What is not clear about rules deemed to be unlawful, unfair and unreasonable ? We won the points we wanted so we have won

That is my take aswell Kaz.

 

[kaz7]

I wonder what tone we will get from neville and co at the weekend , will they wind their necks in a bit and admit the pl rules are unlawful or behave themselves and go with the party line ? Cant wait to find out

 

[Churchlawtonblue]

Comparing the result to a football result is what’s daft.

The PL weren’t trying to win anything. They were trying to keep the current rules in force. They were successful in 23 out of 25 of those.

City were trying to change 25, of which we prevailed in 2.

Now these 2 rule changes might be seismic or they might not be.

The APT rules may be null and void or they may not be.

No one currently knows and we are all awaiting what happens next.

It's the impact that those 2 rules have on the whole APT rules as you state that will decide the outcome.

However, those two judgements alone have already meant that the PL will have to rewrite their rules and that isn't going to be simple by the looks of things.

 

[spacecadet]

I wonder what tone we will get from neville and co at the weekend , will they wind their necks in a bit and admit the pl rules are unlawful or behave themselves and go with the party line ? Cant wait to find out

Do you give Sky monthly money Kaz?

 

[CC1]

I wonder what tone we will get from neville and co at the weekend , will they wind their necks in a bit and admit the pl rules are unlawful or behave themselves and go with the party line ? Cant wait to find out

I think you know the answer to that. They’ll be sick as parrots but pretending to be concerned (through gritted teeth) :-)

 

[Churchlawtonblue]

The contest between their adamancy and that of the majority on here could perhaps be plotted in relative terms on a graph by one of our many accountants ;-)

Nooooo !

 

[ganganvince]

So, seeing as the consensus changes by the minute, did we fucking win or not ?????

Depends on what you think the aim was?

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

It's the impact that those 2 rules have on the whole APT rules as you state that will decide the outcome.

However, those two judgements alone have already meant that the PL will have to rewrite their rules and that isn't going to be simple by the looks of things.

Absolutely, but we don’t know if it will be a simple solution or not.

If it is, the ability to see the PL spreadsheet for FMV calculations is still a big “win”.

 

[kaz7]

Do you give Sky monthly money Kaz?

No, not for a long time , i have firestick , sometimes i will look into the sky coverage to see what they are saying but i tend to watch the yanks feed

 

[Bluewonder]

Hold on, is that Ali mac who used to be with us? He provided a witness statement on behalf of the Premier league?

View attachment 134439

This seems a bit... bent?