The chart for this is on Wikipedia and a United fan at work keeps trotting it out.keith's curle said:City1974 said:Ignore all the nonsense from any ignorant opposition supporters\clubs.
Onwards and upwards City !
At slightly a tangent, and why the League Cup is still a great trophy to win as is any trophy.
Recall the owners targeting 5 trophies in 5 years when Pellegrini started (2 in the bag and hopefully at least 3 more to come in the next 4 years).
I was thinking exactly where we stand as an English club on the all time list of no. of trophies won.
At this time the list I think is:
(includes trophies for League Champs in top division only, FA Cup, League Cup, European Cup\Champs League, Ueafa\Europa League Cup, European Cup Winners Cup, Super Cup, Club World Cup and Charity\Community Shield) :
1) Trafford Rangers - 62 trophies
2) Red scousers - 60 trophies
3) Arsenal the whingers - 46 trophies
4) Chelski - 25 trophies (took off Chelsea winning the Full Members Cup)
5) Blue scousers - 24 trophies
Spurs - 24 trophies
Villa - 24 trophies
8) City - 17 trophies
9) Newcastle - 13 trophies
Notts Forest - 13 trophies
Wolves - 13 trophies
12) Blackburn - 12 trophies
13) Leeds - 9 trophies
Sheff Wed - 9 trophies
Sunderland - 9 trophies
WBA - 9 trophies
17) West Ham - 6 trophies
Would it not be great in at least a decade to surpass Everton, Spurs and Villa. Assuming no other club just below us becomes a major force in that time and we can maintain a position of challenging for every trophy.
Thus all trophies are important.
Good point and interesting post, but...
Why include the Charity Shield? Its not a meaningful trophy. I'm not just choosing to be awkward or pedantic, it simply cannot be considered a real trophy when there are only two teams in contention and its usually played as a glorified friendly. Would be interesting to see the list without it.
Fair points that the Community Shield should be removed from the list of meaningful trophies, as well as the Full Member's Cup, because entry into those competitions were not open to all teams.
By the same token, the World Club Cup, European Super Cup, and maybe some others should not be included as they were not true open competitions. So if you knock all these out of the equation, United fall to the second most successful English club, two trophies behind Liverpool. City can jump a place or two with two more trophy wins.
When pointed out to United and Liverpool fans at work, there was a very mixed reaction.