City Women - Champions and Continental Cup Winners 2016.

Status
Not open for further replies.
What's happening to the local talent??
Completely agree, very disappointing. I thought Flint, for example, was a fine CF with real potential. We seem to be shipping out all of the local lasses and replacing them with either unproven players or experienced players of questionable quality. Nick Cushing is starting to get a Bodgers odour about him.
 
More movement with Brougham moving to Everton and left back in to sit on the bench. What's happening to the local talent??

In this globalised world, you have to shop further a field if you actually want to win things. We could have stuck with all Mancunians, and fought for a top half finish every season. Or we can sign the best players available and actually win things.

Remember that CFG are focusing so much in the women's team because they want to revolutionise the Sport and drag it up to the men's level. You can't do that by refusing to sign anyone born out of earshot of Maine Road/CoMS.
 
Revolutionise the sport? We're not doing anything else the other WSL teams aren't doing. I would argue that the player signed is not actually any better than the player who has left? I thought signing a player improves the squad not keeps it on the same level? As long as Stokes is fit she wont play. The US College 'soccer' system is not actually of a great standard. Ireland are outside the Top 30 in the world and have never qualified for a major championship. Ordinary player. Something strange here? And I still remember the signing of Sarah Wiltshire...

Part of the WSL application is to provide a player pathway for regional or local talent, question if we have done this...I see no reserve players coming through.
 
Revolutionise the sport? We're not doing anything else the other WSL teams aren't doing. I would argue that the player signed is not actually any better than the player who has left? I thought signing a player improves the squad not keeps it on the same level? As long as Stokes is fit she wont play. The US College 'soccer' system is not actually of a great standard. Ireland are outside the Top 30 in the world and have never qualified for a major championship. Ordinary player. Something strange here? And I still remember the signing of Sarah Wiltshire...

Part of the WSL application is to provide a player pathway for regional or local talent, question if we have done this...I see no reserve players coming through.

What other teams deliberately designed their training grounds to let the women have their own area but with full interactivity with the men's teams? What other teams let their female players do pre-season fitness training with the male players? What other teams have custom-built stadia for the women's team right next to the men's ground, instead of relegating them to playing on a rented Conference ground 5 miles outside of the city? What other teams send their women's teams on expensive trips to the Middle East to be showcased for the club's owners, rather than sidelining them to the level of supporting act for the men? That's what I mean about revolutionising the sport. The exact same is happening in Melbourne. When players join either of the two MCWFCs, they don't say they are joining because of the prestige of the club, they say they are joining because they've never found a club which treats them so professionally nor throws so many resources at them.

As for the players we've signed not being better than the players we let go, are you really sure about that, or are you just going off your view that because our newest signing is Irish, she can't be up to the standard of the other players in the league? What about the signing of Jane Ross, who has a 1 in 2 goal rate in 78 appearances for the Scottish national team - a team which may not have reached the Women's World Cup but only failed to qualify after losing a play-off against the Netherlands - the same Netherlands who almost matched Japan, the losing finalist, in their knock-out game? Or how about our new Swedish striker, who has already scored 21 goals for her country - and Sweden, unlike Ireland or Scotland, have a better than 50% rate of reaching major international semi-finals at women's level? How are they "not actually any better" than the players who have left, virtually all of whom haven't had a single cap and most of whom failed to break into the first XI last season?
 
we're gonna need a bigger boat!

I'm so amused, and just to amuse myself further...

What other teams deliberately designed their training grounds to let the women have their own area but with full interactivity with the men's teams? No-one, neither did City, the Women's team were on board after plans and building had started. But Doncaster are building are training ground just for their women's side...Chelsea use Cobham, Arsenal Colnoy, Sunderland Academy of Light etc...

What other teams let their female players do pre-season fitness training with the male players? No where have I seen the women's team doing pre season with the men's as the season start at different times that actually would be impossible...perhaps enlighten me. But Liverpool did do previous training session with their teams at Melwood.

What other teams have custom-built stadia for the women's team right next to the men's ground, instead of relegating them to playing on a rented Conference ground 5 miles outside of the city? Wasn't build for the women was it...again benefactors of a already conceived project. But Barcelona do it.

What other teams send their women's teams on expensive trips to the Middle East to be showcased for the club's owners, rather than sidelining them to the level of supporting act for the men? Arsenal are touring Spain playing the like of Bayern Munich and Liverpool have gone to South Africa. Go on skyscanner for the rest...

That's what I mean about revolutionising the sport. The exact same is happening in Melbourne. When players join either of the two MCWFCs, they don't say they are joining because of the prestige of the club, they say they are joining because they've never found a club which treats them so professionally nor throws so many resources at them. All players say this when joining a club...standard.
As for the players we've signed not being better than the players we let go, are you really sure about that, or are you just going off your view that because our newest signing is Irish, she can't be up to the standard of the other players in the league? No im going off the view that I know women's football. good long throw though.

What about the signing of Jane Ross, who has a 1 in 2 goal rate in 78 appearances for the Scottish national team - a team which may not have reached the Women's World Cup but only failed to qualify after losing a play-off against the Netherlands - the same Netherlands who almost matched Japan, the losing finalist, in their knock-out game? Don't have a problem with that. We play a with one striker so unsure how she fits. Better players out there that were available IMO.

Or how about our new Swedish striker, who has already scored 21 goals for her country - and Sweden, unlike Ireland or Scotland, have a better than 50% rate of reaching major international semi-finals at women's level? Again don't believe I've mentioned that she isn't talented, although has done nothing at PSG for 6 months. Hope it goes well for her.

Im off to file my nails.

How are they "not actually any better" than the players who have left, virtually all of whom haven't had a single cap and most of whom failed to break into the first XI last season? The depth of the English player pool is larger than Irelands.
 
Looked at the squad Nightingale's name is missing. Any one know anyting?
She's no longer listed as a player on the OS and her MCWFC profile has been pulled from the FA WSL site so it doesn't look good. I've tweeted her asking if she's been released. Would be sad news if she has.
 
Really? You think so? She's long serving as well isn't she? You would think City would've have put something out if she was released? Classless if they haven't bothered. Guess we'll watch this space...
 
Pity the Club aren't as ruthless with their male counterparts, some (most) of them need releasing and quickly.

In an ideal world they would. it's a tad more difficult when a player is on £100+k a week with a number of years left on their contracts though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.