Were you moaning all last season when Joe was #1 and Willy was #2? If I could be arsed I would check your post history but I will leave that one with you.
What I would like to politely ask you though is using a scoring system of 0-10 how would you rate Joe & Willy against, lets say:
Shot stopping
penalty saving
Decision making
Command of the area
leadership
Distribution
catching
football ability
Please feel free to add any other criteria. Not a wind up and a gen question
Yes i said last season caballero wasn't good enough and was a disaster waiting to happen
Shot stopping Hart - 8 Cab - 6
penalty saving Hart 7 Willy 7 ( joe for the fact that he has stopped penalties form messi and ibra big nose amongst others and cab for the CC last year against the dippers)
Decision making Hart 8 comes for crosses and get most of them right..excellent at punching the ball in a crowded box and excellent at one on ones which requires great decision making Willy 6 - looks unsure on crosses, at when to go one on one
Command of the area Hart 8 Willy 6....rarely comes for crosses, doesn't organise the defence, whereas hart does both considerably better
leadership Hart 9 Willy 5 (and thats being generous)
Distribution Hart 6 Willy 7-8
catching Hart - rarely catches under pressure and always elects to punch but rarely drops anything when does go to catch.....same with willy so difficult to mark either of them
football ability - to me other than tactical awareness that is the same as distribution
You also missed one on ones situations which is particularly specialised within goalkeepers - hart is far superior in this as well as I've already mentioned above
Im absolutely sure you will disagree with me on those but since you asked there they are.
Im also unsure why you are asking me to compare Joe and Willy as I've already stated several times that even though i think Joe should be kept as number 2 i don't expect him to do that and expect him to leave....Im guessing (and i could be wrong on this) its cause
you think my comments on Caballero are related to me wanting Joe hart as number two ........... my comments on caballero have (and lets be absolutely clear on this) NOTHING to do with Joe Hart....its now about who is number 2 to bravo and caballero isn't good enough...its the same argument as when you take ferna and gudongan out of the central midfield engine room , the next available options are too much of a downgrade (delph and fernando - they too aint good enough long term)