Club Badge (merged)

[IanBishopsHaircut]

the majority of the fan badges though have been created using the older badges as a design template anyway.

They are still modern interpretations though...doesn't give the club much room with regards to updated versions of the old badge...at least without stepping on someone's toes...Gav for example has done loads of permutations

 

[Gary James]

Thanks Gary. Knew id read it somewhere. I take back my apology Metalartin ;-) So as it stands the original has 2 titles & 2 fa cups. Think im best staying quiet lol.

2 titles, 3 FAC, 1LC & 1 ECWC! It was worn at 1934 homecoming and was still being used in 1972. Actually, an illuminated version of the original, pre Rose, circular badge was still on the external wall of the CitySocial Club in the late 1980s!

 

[Citizen of Legoland]

the majority of the fan badges though have been created using the older badges as a design template anyway.

It's probably in the BM Ts & Cs that you lose all copyright to posted material anyway.

 

[blueparrot]

It's probably in the BM Ts & Cs that you lose all copyright to posted material anyway.

Does that mean Ric has all the copyright to Geekin Gavs creations ?

 

[Citizen of Legoland]

Does that mean Ric has all the copyright to Geekin Gavs creations ?

No, my mistake - just checked and poster retains copyright, nothing to see here, move on ....

 

[aguero93:20]

2 titles, 3 FAC, 1LC & 1 ECWC! It was worn at 1934 homecoming and was still being used in 1972. Actually, an illuminated version of the original, pre Rose, circular badge was still on the external wall of the CitySocial Club in the late 1980s!

So what you're trying to say is, if we're measuring by success the Rose badge is pretty fucked?

 

[Keepingthefaithsince1976]

2 titles, 3 FAC, 1LC & 1 ECWC! It was worn at 1934 homecoming and was still being used in 1972. Actually, an illuminated version of the original, pre Rose, circular badge was still on the external wall of the CitySocial Club in the late 1980s!

Thanks Gary. Your a fountain of City knowledge. Tbh I was originally looking at the point as some fans were saying the eagle badge had covered our most successful period. If the eagle does go I won't be on here gloating. ..just quietly pleased that I'm among like minded folk.

 

[Shaelumstash]

They are still modern interpretations though...doesn't give the club much room with regards to updated versions of the old badge...at least without stepping on someone's toes...Gav for example has done loads of permutations

I'm sure any genuine blue wouldn't try and stitch up the club for copyright infringement based on a design they've knocked up on posted on Bluemoon. You'd certainly hope not.

As Gav himself said, his popular design is not anything original, he's just modernised our original badge, and included the circle border from the NYCFC badge.

As I pointed out about the FCUM badge, although that is similar, it's pretty much a rip off of our badge from the 1930s. I'm sure in any copyright case the club could produce enough evidence that they owned the intellectual property to the original design, and any updated version knocked up by a fan shouldn't affect that.

 

[geoff clipp]

They are still modern interpretations though...doesn't give the club much room with regards to updated versions of the old badge...at least without stepping on someone's toes...Gav for example has done loads of permutations

Slightly changing/updating somebody else's already existing and copyrighted ideas doesn't give you your own copyright. If Gav or whoever started selling merch with their amended versions of the badge the club could put a stop to it if they wanted.

 

[Keepingthefaithsince1976]

What I'm more worried about is there has been so many variations of the badge made up by fans..will the club be scared to do something similar and have one of the fan designers sue for copyright/ripping off the design or something? I know we would like to think it wouldn't happen

Highly unlikely. The club could do a lot worse than asking geekingav to help.