Club Badge (merged)

[GeekinGav]

right .... held off doing this ..... as i dont advocate for an eagle. Done it so i can have closure on the whole thing as its the only one i havent done properly.

Why Purple? Selfish reasons, its my favourite colour and thought it is something different.

Anyhoo. That's me finally finished.

 

[SWP's back]

@Ric following on from the chat about a vote the other week, I think it's now possible to create a shortlist. Not everyone will have their first choice included, but I've tried to select 5 that represent the views of the majority of posters on here.

We know it's going to be round, so I've included 5 round badges, 2 with eagles, 2 with three river shields, and one with a rose.

Everyone has their own ideas on trim and colour scheme, as reflected in Gav's post last week that had 30 different designs on. Perhaps everyone's first choice is not one of these options, but I hope there is enough variety that people can vote on the core design they like best, even if they would make alterations in a perfect world.
A.

B.

C.

D.

E.

B for me.

 

[IanBishopsHaircut]

right .... held off doing this ..... as i dont advocate for an eagle. Done it so i can have closure on the whole thing as its the only one i havent done properly.

Why Purple? Selfish reasons, its my favourite colour and thought it is something different.

Anyhoo. That's me finally finished.

That would actually be quite cool if you replaced the purple with sky blue

 

[Elbow beards]

right .... held off doing this ..... as i dont advocate for an eagle. Done it so i can have closure on the whole thing as its the only one i havent done properly.

Why Purple? Selfish reasons, its my favourite colour and thought it is something different.

Anyhoo. That's me finally finished.

We have a winner, bring back the Eagle!!!

 

[Gordyola]

D without the stars = Gav's one but blue not purple

 

[GeekinGav]

Might do a blue one later if I get time

 

[Shaelumstash]

right .... held off doing this ..... as i dont advocate for an eagle. Done it so i can have closure on the whole thing as its the only one i havent done properly.

Why Purple? Selfish reasons, its my favourite colour and thought it is something different.

Anyhoo. That's me finally finished.

You're the best designer on here Gav, much better than the in house design team at City imo. If anyone could make this work it would be you. But you can't polish a turd.

Why on earth anyone would want a round badge with an eagle inside is just completely beyond me. It doesn't look anything like a City badge, it looks like some kind of US Security Service badge.

I understand the eagle means something to some people and they want to keep it. But I don't believe anyone can say with a straight face that the eagle looks better inside a circle than the existing badge.

 

[tailspin747]

right .... held off doing this ..... as i dont advocate for an eagle. Done it so i can have closure on the whole thing as its the only one i havent done properly.

Why Purple? Selfish reasons, its my favourite colour and thought it is something different.

Anyhoo. That's me finally finished.

I'm not normally a fan of the eagle but that is a nice design. Excellent work as always Gav. I think I may be a convert.

 

[blue roo]

B for me.

C for me , clean and crisp.

 

[blueparrot]

Might do a blue one later if I get time

Not quite closure yet then :)