Club Badge (merged)

[g180aj]

Ok, so honest opinions Blues, which one do you prefer:
A.

or

B:

the second one but with the rose on it like the top would be great because the shield looks weird on the top one.

 

[andyhinch]

Can I vote for C ?

 

[Cheadle_hulmeBlue]

I dont see how that badge is more of an identifiable branding than the one we have now. I look at it and see Man City, but thats cos Im in my 40's and grew up with that badge. I dont other people will see that and get it?

they will grow up with this one and then identify with it. ...

imo A very simplistic modern throwback to the 70's badge there

 

[IWasHere]

I expected a professional, modern take using elements of the old badges. In a similar way to those done by GeekinGav. Not this childish attempt.

This has to be up there with the worst design

 

[CatMan]

Can I vote for C ?

Keep what we've got.

Very disappointed.

 

[Florida Blue]

very similar when you break em down.

 

[SWP's back]

I was expecting bad, but not this bad.

If this was offered up as a design on here is would have been laughed out of town compared to Gav's designs. People would be saying "Have you done that on MS Paint?"

They've clearly taken inspiration from Arsenal for a really simplified design, but they've missed it by a huge margin. It looks like a cartoon and it's actually a little bit embarrassing.

The eagle and the Melbourne badges are leagues ahead of this in terms of design quality, and I hate those two badges too.

An abomination.

So you like it then?

 

[dickie davies]

I immensely dislike our current badge but I wouldn't swap it for that

 

[super_city_si]

this could be it as well, its also registered

Now that one is fucking smart!!!

 

[Stuuuuuu]

I don't like:
* the ridiculous cartoony style
* the inappropriate red rose of Lancashire
* the way the word City is bizarrely horizontal but Manchester is not
* the silly popping-out of the badge

I do like:
* the fact that it's pretty much the proper City badge.