Club Badge (merged)

[Gary James]

By the way I like the badge!

 

[Keepingthefaithsince1976]

and though not massive changes, the bottom version answers much of the criticism (border too fat, no FC/gFootball Club, Shield oveflap, schoolboy effort!) and looks much better

Prefer the club one because i like space.

 

[Ban-jani]

By the way I like the badge!

If it's good enough for Gary, it's good enough for me.

 

[ballinio]

It's on the BBC sports page. The one on the right!

One on the left is beautifull

 

[failsworthblueboy]

If it's good enough for Gary, it's good enough for me.

Yes but if Gary has commented on liking the badge before it's official release, is he talking about the badge that you all are. Just a thought !!!

 

[HoJon]

The shield overlapping into the circle, to me, looks ridiculous. Amateurish in fact.
But, if we beat Sunderland, I'll forgive them.

 

[George Hannah]

By the way I like the badge!

It's a disaster daahling

 

[Keepingthefaithsince1976]

Yeah love that space...ffs

?

 

[Keepingthefaithsince1976]

Not really, they could then make the shield smaller as they wouldn't have to have the "3 rivers" as noticeable and distinguishable as the rose.

Or they could have just fucked the The Warner Bros badge off entirely and kept them all within an inner circle.

I think the shield was an element fans voted for. I didn't but I'm happy the eagle has gone in fairness. The club were never going to please everyone. I think its a shame their are so many negative view points on here. The club made an effort & included fans. They need to be applauded for making the effort. I'm not including you in this but their are loads of posts in this thread that imply the club have made a mistake. The reality is fans views differ and there are lots of positive views too.

 

[Keepingthefaithsince1976]

I'm not really missing the point. And I wouldnt have had a problem with a popular vote.

You may think the design looks better without the rivers or the rose, but I just don't think design considerations are that important when choosing what is and what isnt important to be part of a badge.

The rose and rivers may make it harder to create a badge of your liking but for me thats tough shit. People think the rivers are important and the rose is important.

You can't just remove important symbols because the badge looks better.

Good points.