Colin Shindler in the Mail

If there's one thing I hate about our new found wealth, it's the apologetic "fan" journalists we have. Principally Shindler and Simon Hattenstone at The Guardian. Seems fairly transparent to me what they're doing; the written media on the whole are opposed to City's assault on the top four, and these sycophants are trying to keep onside of the press so deem fit to criticise the team they supposedly love.

But they don't speak for us, the man on the street supporter. Indeed, it's only really the aforementioned hacks who can accentuate the negatives in what's happening at City - every genuine fan I've spoken to feels quite differently.

What really riles me is just how out of touch they are, and the sense that they feel somehow superior to your regular fan. They seemed to revel in our ineptitude in the past, as they could be self deprecating and almost embarrassed about the fact they supported our club. "Plucky old City". Loveable, but essentially rubbish.

Suddenly we're in a position of power and bizarrely they don't like it. But it's a stance I can't comprehend. Surely if you were a true City fan you'd relish the fact that we are in a poisition to threaten the hegemony of the top four?! Every other City fan I know does.

"Come writers and critics
Who prophesize with your pen
And keep your eyes wide
The chance won't come again
And don't speak too soon
For the wheel's still in spin
And there's no tellin' who
That it's namin'.
For the loser now
Will be later to win
For the times they are a-changin'."
 
My comment which will not be published:

You know, you profess to love the club, but don't actually give any reasons why you now dislike it. You use poetic language but don't actually give any opinion or facts. I see that you also love the club up until it was sold to a foreigner. You also match other classic players up, and describe anybody who is foreign as not as good as their English counterpart. You are the whore Colin. You have sold you love of the club that you possessed for decades to get a cheap bump in readership for a short time. You should be ashamed of yourself. I can for the majority of City fans and say that we are certainly ashamed to have you associated with the club. If you are that disappointed about us, then please support a more ethical club, such as the untainted, Anglo-Saxon Manchester United or Chelsea.
 
He should realise that if City carried on winning sweet fa for the next 10 years he might be looking at grankids in rag shirts.
Give me the whore anyday.
 
Says Schindler the author of a poor book whose very title belittled blues, and a man who has made money out of our club

Always regarded this man with contempt
 
Schindler has written a couple of good books TBH...

But I heard him and David Bernstein on radio 5 a while back at the time of the takeover...he was embarrasssing....sounded clueless and totally,hopelesley out of touch.

He now just sounds like another London-based media luvvy "how we used to live" professional Northerner,lamenting over supposedly "glorious yesterdays" while never actually taking any part in the hard yards of it for over a decade.

He should shut up now.
 
very droll and boring . is he a fan of city or a fan of losing i am getting pissed off with the shit were getting. i dont mind it coming from other teams you expect it . but there are so called city fans in the papers on tv and on the radio giving it wah wah im not happy with the way were spending money wah wah im not happy with the wages were paying i know talksport is shit but some so called city fans always ring in saying how bad it is what were doing (fuck off) (just the other day a fan rang up agreeing with mike parry how bad we are trying to sign him and him bullying clubs etc), then he started saying how shit the atmosphere is at eastlands. .. well fuck off if you dont like it go and support oldham or alty

rant almost over
 
I quite liked his book, but after listening to him on that Abu Dhabi blues radio show a few months back, and after reading this, I've lost respect for him.

I just hate the way he seems embarrased about supporting us, and his "City will no longer be everybodys 2nd favourite team" manner. Sorry what? I would much rather have the press hoping we fail, and Fergie belittling us, than playing York on a cold December night, and people pitying us, and saying "oh aren't those City fans loyal" in patronising tones, while United win a few more Cups.

He just sounds like Grandpa off The Simpsons, banging on about the good old days, and how awful everything is now.
 
Damocles said:
My comment which will not be published:

You know, you profess to love the club, but don't actually give any reasons why you now dislike it. You use poetic language but don't actually give any opinion or facts. I see that you also love the club up until it was sold to a foreigner. You also match other classic players up, and describe anybody who is foreign as not as good as their English counterpart. You are the whore Colin. You have sold you love of the club that you possessed for decades to get a cheap bump in readership for a short time. You should be ashamed of yourself. I can for the majority of City fans and say that we are certainly ashamed to have you associated with the club. If you are that disappointed about us, then please support a more ethical club, such as the untainted, Anglo-Saxon Manchester United or Chelsea.


fantastic mate
 
I've just read it again for the second time and it made the hairs on the back of my neck stand up with embarrassment. I dont think this guy is a football fan at all. He saw a city team that won things. I only managed to see, as a small lad, the league cup in 76 and I want to see us win something else.

Piss off and write another boring book and leave us to our team.
 
Damocles said:
My comment which will not be published:

You know, you profess to love the club, but don't actually give any reasons why you now dislike it. You use poetic language but don't actually give any opinion or facts. I see that you also love the club up until it was sold to a foreigner. You also match other classic players up, and describe anybody who is foreign as not as good as their English counterpart. You are the whore Colin. You have sold you love of the club that you possessed for decades to get a cheap bump in readership for a short time. You should be ashamed of yourself. I can for the majority of City fans and say that we are certainly ashamed to have you associated with the club. If you are that disappointed about us, then please support a more ethical club, such as the untainted, Anglo-Saxon Manchester United or Chelsea.
Unfortunately I have to agree. There seems more to the rant than is wanted from most respectable people. I'm concerned about any anti-arab feelings being covertly expressed by him and the Guardian (in previous articles).
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.