Healdplace
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 May 2013
- Messages
- 15,985
To clarify I am NOT saying it was not seen. As I said I presumed strongly it was. And I understand the reasons why it is difficult to know whether to act swiftly and be wrong if the final data peters out.There are a few problems with both approaches.
can you really act suppressively with data that is 'flashy' and could simply represent a steady trend but the reporting means it looks like an increase? Equally should you wait and see what happens when the reporting date data is telling you things are going up? 'Out of date' is a misnomer, as it represents the actual date, but i understand you just use that as a label.
for what it's worth, i am very confident that there are batch processes that compare both sets of data. The speed at which variant %age breakdown of cases was produced (weeks ago, not recently) told me that to do that, there was sequencing already happening ages ago. Then there is access to data we simply dont have in good time, that were initially used as parameters in the crappy tier system.
the communication between the data production and the people who make decisions on what to do with it, or level of interest in what it means (across the board) is another matter entirely. Yes i think you're right in that Bolton data was pretty obviously going up but i am afraid i completely disagree that it was not seen in public health, it's just a question on why there wasn't 'apparent' action.
I do not envy anyone in the job of making these decisions.
I just feel the media maybe could have been made more aware and perhaps issued warnings about a need to be cautious just in case. Or seen it themselves and acted proactively not retroactively.
But the media do not investigate much these days. They really are sheep being fed by others and going baaa in. the local accent of their ethos and readership.
I trust the scientists to make the right call. And the government to try. Though they have a tough job balancing responsibilities. I am neither a scientist or politician and envy neither in these circustances. But guess I am a kind of journalist and I feel they have been very poor in the past 18 months.
Last edited: