Ray78 said:
Trouble with Vieira is that he is another top player who hasn't got the experience in fully managing the seniors. Especially when our top 4 status isn't secure and he was fully concentrating on the EDS side. You can mention Giggs but he was only given 4 games (they had their replacement already in place) he was still registered as a player and United had nothing to play for as they had no chance in qualifying for either the Champions League or the Europa League. It has been a while since Vieira has had full contact with our squad.
I never get the experience argument to be honest, plenty of first time managers have done a good job and plenty of experienced ones have done a shit one, and vice versa, whoever we pick is a gamble, some top rated managers have dies on their arses, sometimes it is circumstance
Paddy could not do any worse, he has played under very good managers and certainly knows the benefits of a functioning midfield, in fairness though others would be better placed with how he sets up the eds lads as i don't watch them, this all depends on if the club are going to sack pellegrini now or in the summer, not sacking him at all is something i cannot contemplate
with six games to go if we sack him now i think at least paddy has knowledge of the premiership and has seen our players first hand, the argentinian would be a bigger gamble over six games for a CL spot