Dyke's Proposals

[Skip Donoghue]

Re: Dykes Proposals

Fuming

Couldn't give a fuck how many 'home grown' players we have in our team

I support City not England and I want the very best players in the WORLD here

Ridiculous and will only weaken the Premier League

No it won't there is plenty of talented local and British footballers coming through at youth level.....the problem is there is no route for these players to get over the final hurdle and into the 1st team, bringing young players to City from all around the world doesn't work and never has it is a flawed method, you end up bring ing the kids family over paying them a decent wage to live here and eventually they go home when their contract is up ie Denis Suarez, now at Barca and if we are to believe reports knocking on the 1st teams door....where has this for example benefitted City?

We get a big hefty fee when he plays for the first team?

Woopy doo....a few million, as I said a flawed system, I would rather have kept the player who is good enough for Barca's 1st team than collect a few million in a transfer fee, wouldn't you? Unfortunately for us that was never an option, that's why bringing foriegn players in 99% of the time doesn't work

 

[aguero93:20]

Re: Dykes Proposals

We get a big hefty fee when he plays for the first team?

Woopy doo....a few million, as I said a flawed system, I would rather have kept the player who is good enough for Barca's 1st team than collect a few million in a transfer fee, wouldn't you? Unfortunately for us that was never an option

I would rather the few million for a player who never looked anything special in our EDS team compared to his team mates tbh because either we weren't the right place for him to be or he didn't want to be here.

 

[BosnianDiamond]

I don't see what is the uproar about? This would only benefit the Premier League teams because their "B" players would get valuable playing time.

The "B" teams could not progress to championship or compete in FA or League cups, so how exactly would this hurt the lower league teams?

 

[BlueBearBoots]

Wouldn't this scupper the loan system too? Sounds an all round bad idea to me

 

[IanBishopsHaircut]

Never mind

 

[greasedupdeafguy]

I don't see what is the uproar about? This would only benefit the Premier League teams because their "B" players would get valuable playing time.

The "B" teams could not progress to championship or compete in FA or League cups, so how exactly would this hurt the lower league teams?

It will destroy attendances below the championship. Just look at Spain and Portugal.

League one is in the top 10 average attendances in Europe.

 

[uwe_returns]

Danny Mills is on the commission. Danny Mills. Danny fucking Mills.

 

[BosnianDiamond]

Re: Dykes Proposals

in principle a good idea, in practice very bad, i think the lower leagues would suffer, maybe a cup for lower leagues inclusive of prem B teams would be better idea, though maybe just a cup for under 18 prem B teams, will give game time for the young uns, fuck knows surely must be an idea out there somewhere

I just cannot give a rat's tits about England..in fact..the only time I do give a shit is when they play meaningless friendlies that get in the way of me watching City

British players should be in a team on merit..anything else is unacceptable

I do agree with this.

 

[aguero93:20]

Danny Mills is on the commission. Danny Mills. Danny fucking Mills.

Expert in developing young footballers mate... no, couldn't even finish that post. Still, there's a halfway decent chance he knows what he's doing better than Dyke does.

 

[BlueBearBoots]

Apparently City, utd, Liverpool and Arsenal support the B team idea