Ederson - 2018/2019 performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
BosnianBlue said:
My kid is goalkeeper so I know the default in keeper's training is not to use legs, but that kind f shot is not possible to save but with legs. Sorry, but de Gea is not conceding that, at least not from the first shot. I know it's everyone's guess where ball goes after leg save but when there's no other option it's legit to do it with leg and at least give yourself a chance.
Click to expand...
He was still hurting from landing on his hip,maybe he couldn't do anything with his legs at that moment?
 
BosnianBlue said:
My kid is goalkeeper so I know the default in keeper's training is not to use legs, but that kind f shot is not possible to save but with legs. Sorry, but de Gea is not conceding that, at least not from the first shot. I know it's everyone's guess where ball goes after leg save but when there's no other option it's legit to do it with leg and at least give yourself a chance.
Click to expand...
I agree that De Gea would probably have saved that but taken as a whole Ederson is much the better keeper for City.
Our style of play would have De Gea looking like a fish out of water in no time and the odd acrobatic save that he would have chance to make would be a poor substitute for the fluidity that Eddie gives us.
De Gea is not exactly a stone wall at the moment as the number of soft goals he’s conceded lately would show.
 
Deepest Blue said:
I agree that De Gea would probably have saved that but taken as a whole Ederson is much the better keeper for City.
Our style of play would have De Gea looking like a fish out of water in no time and the odd acrobatic save that he would have chance to make would be a poor substitute for the fluidity that Eddie gives us.
De Gea is not exactly a stone wall at the moment as the number of soft goals he’s conceded lately would show.
Click to expand...

No arguments about that, I'd rather have Ederson for our style of game, than pretty much anyone else.
 
BosnianBlue said:
My kid is goalkeeper so I know the default in keeper's training is not to use legs, but that kind f shot is not possible to save but with legs. Sorry, but de Gea is not conceding that, at least not from the first shot. I know it's everyone's guess where ball goes after leg save but when there's no other option it's legit to do it with leg and at least give yourself a chance.
Click to expand...
55 goals against De Gea this season says he is letting that get past him!
 
Mid Wales blue said:
55 goals against De Gea this season says he is letting that get past him!
Click to expand...

It doesn't. It might get past him of course, but he's very unique keeper with his leg work and probably saves that.

De Gea had pretty bad season compared to few before, but number of goals conceded by some team is in no way, shape or form, only due to keeper. Keeper can help or make it worse in few or 10, but defending through season is collective duty.
 
BosnianBlue said:
My kid is goalkeeper so I know the default in keeper's training is not to use legs, but that kind f shot is not possible to save but with legs. Sorry, but de Gea is not conceding that, at least not from the first shot. I know it's everyone's guess where ball goes after leg save but when there's no other option it's legit to do it with leg and at least give yourself a chance.
Click to expand...

And my grandad was one of the greatest goal keepers to play the game (despite being a ****), that doesn’t make me an authority. The balls are like canons these days, to think he’d stop it from that distance is presumptuous.... anyway, he saved us numerous times last night by being commanding, he’s the dogs bollocks for me!
 
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:
And my grandad was one of the greatest goal keepers to play the game (despite being a ****), that doesn’t make me an authority. The balls are like canons these days, to think he’d stop it from that distance is presumptuous.... anyway, he saved us numerous times last night by being commanding, he’s the dogs bollocks for me!
Click to expand...

OK, than each shot on a goal is not saveable by that "cannon" logic. Of course it's not easy, but being elite player means you do some things that are not easy, but possible. That was possible to save.

I completely agree he had a good game overall and said that in the first post after the game. But that shot is saveable. I'd go as far to say that it is saveable to many with any decent reflex who are not trained to dive. And goalkeepers are trained to dive. And my personal opinion is that it is mistake for shots like that. No way to dive fast enough.
 
BosnianBlue said:
It doesn't. It might get past him of course, but he's very unique keeper with his leg work and probably saves that.

De Gea had pretty bad season compared to few before, but number of goals conceded by some team is in no way, shape or form, only due to keeper. Keeper can help or make it worse in few or 10, but defending through season is collective duty.
Click to expand...

Which is it?

"Sorry, but de Gea is not conceding that"

"but he's very unique keeper with his leg work and probably saves that"
 
mosssideblue said:
Which is it?

"Sorry, but de Gea is not conceding that"

"but he's very unique keeper with his leg work and probably saves that"
Click to expand...

We're not on the court mate nor I am magician to know it. You'd have to give me some margin in my literal expressing. Or not. As I don't care a lot. Peace.

But he is saving that. Very, very probably
 
mosssideblue said:
Gen Q and I don't know but from the ball leaving Sons foot, how long do you think Eddie has to process what he sees and reacts as you suggest?
Click to expand...
Barely any time at all. Many GK will try what Eddie did and fail to save, but those who goes with the other option will probably save it. He almost had time to go down and save it, that tells me he definitely would’ve saved it had he used his foot.
 
mosssideblue said:
Gen Q and I don't know but from the ball leaving Sons foot, how long do you think Eddie has to process what he sees and reacts as you suggest?
Click to expand...
I think de gea may have saved that but very few others. Not many keepers react with their feet the way de gea does. Most goalies would go down to their side as ederson did but there’s just not enough time from that distance. I’m not blaming Eddie at all, his training has taught him to get his body behind it. You react in that situation and his instinct was to dive. De geas is to kick.
 
super_city_si said:
I think de gea may have saved that but very few others. Not many keepers react with their feet the way de gea does. Most goalies would go down to their side as ederson did but there’s just not enough time from that distance. I’m not blaming Eddie at all, his training has taught him to get his body behind it. You react in that situation and his instinct was to dive. De geas is to steal donuts.
Click to expand...

Edited
 
Doesn’t appear to on the training video from yesterday. Must be a big doubt for tomorrow against Palace
 
who cares about the goal????

Eds has been great all season, i m not dwelling on the goal and i m not looking to blame anyone for the goal. he s a goalie ,they all get beaten by goals all season.

grow up ye whingers!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top