Ederson or Hart. Who gets into the team of the decade?

mosssideblue said:
Im not dissing Joe, and yes he played his part in our early successes no one would argue that. I do think many though could see he had several weaknesses. Again, Golden Gloves are won by the team, its just a nice touch to give the keeper praise they would not normally get

I simply dont rate him as much as some do.

Your second para seems to contradict your first though if I am reading it correctly
Click to expand...

what am saying is to be world class you have to play in the best teams or play at united or liverpool ??? so manchester city be top dogs in england joe was a great great keeper, yes it helps if your back 4 in front of you is good, but that is also down to your keeper with control and placement when it comes to corners free kicks and stop stopping

the team of the decade you must start with joe in goal, yes ederson will over take joe in the next 10 years with being a special keeper and a different style the game now needs, but for the foundation of what we are today joe hart is the only pick for me and its to early for ederson to take the spot ??
 
ancoats said:
what am saying is to be world class you have to play in the best teams or play at united or liverpool ??? so manchester city be top dogs in england joe was a great great keeper, yes it helps if your back 4 in front of you is good, but that is also down to your keeper with control and placement when it comes to corners free kicks and stop stopping

the team of the decade you must start with joe in goal, yes ederson will over take joe in the next 10 years with being a special keeper and a different style the game now needs, but for the foundation of what we are today joe hart is the only pick for me and its to early for ederson to take the spot ??
Click to expand...

We will never agree so will leave it there
 
As people have said, different keeper for different styles of team play. Eddy doesnt gets as exposed as Harty used to, so doesnt have as many saves to make. Eddy is involved as another defender when we have the ball around the area, Harty wouldnt have been able to do this. Put Eddy in Cardiff's team and i dont see a big difference, but he works for us. Harty saved Burnley quite often but wouldnt work now for us. Pep is astute enough to know that its not about who is the best, but who is the best for our style.
Answer though, Harty for now. At his peak for 3-4 years at just the right time for us.
 
mosssideblue said:
Correct, you win both with the team supporting you.


Other than shot stopping & 1v1, what exactly was Joe good at ?

For me:

command of the box was weak
Catching was non existent
Flapping / wafting, I'll grant you
Distribution - appalling
Ball skills at his feet - none
Click to expand...
Lol,no wonder you went into bat for juliet so hard,you could have saved several months of posts if you just said this is what you think of joe to start with
 
chaddblue said:
Yeah I know, was joking

Difficult to choose between peak JH and Eddie. Both perfect for our teams at the time
Click to expand...
My apologies

We have seen some amazing saves from joe hart. Spurs away, when I thought I was watching joe corrigan , all over again.

But Ederson is something else, if pep left and could take a player with him, it would be him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.