I think some people forget just how toxic things were between both clubs and both sets of fans back then. Games between City and Everton had been pretty tasty for years off the field anyway but often slipped under the radar of a wider audience compared to when United and Liverpool played each other. I’ve seen more trouble at matches between us and Everton down the years than I ever have in games against Liverpool. Sure, back in the day it wasn’t a walk in the park going to Anfield but when we played both teams in 1981 in the League Cup semi (against Liverpool) and in the FA Cup 6th round (against Everton), many City fans who were at both reckon that the match at Goodison saw more trouble. Thankfully, I was too young to go to either!
Fast forward to our takeover and the Lescott transfer saga. I get that Moyes was desperate to hang on to him or failing that try and get us to cough up as much as possible for him but some of the comments he came out with about City stoked the fire. IIRC, it was Moyes (and Everton) who disclosed news of our bids and Hughes only started talking freely to the press about it following that. I recall an interview with Moyes in one of the Sunday red tops before Lescott signed saying that Chelsea conduct their transfer business far more respectfully than City do. A bit weird considering Chelsea’s very public tapping up of Ashley Cole just a few years before.
Naturally this seeped through to the Everton fans and when we played them for the first time after the Lescott transfer at Goodison, their fans were bang up for it and they won quite comfortably. We then played them at home in a midweek game a couple of months later. This was a rearranged game from very early in the season and for months we’d been banking on this game in hand to get an advantage over Spurs in the fight for 4th place and again we came up short. I can still hear the chants of Everton fans singing “2 nil, and we spent fuck all” ringing round our stadium. Of course, these days Everton have plenty of money (and appear to be getting things right following a few false starts) and I think their fans can see things a bit more from our side. Let’s also not forget that when Moyes went to United, he pissed off a lot of Evertonians with his attitude when trying to poach Baines and Fellaini with that pathetic lowball bid. A thawing in relations is probably also down to us stopping their neighbours winning the league in 2014 and 2019 plus from our side we can now see what they’ve had to put up with in their own city for years in terms of the cult like mentality of some Liverpool fans. However, I bet when fans are finally allowed back in matches between us and Everton will still be lively enough!