Fabian Delph

Status
Not open for further replies.
On the face of it, not an inspirational signing and if he wasn't British, we wouldn't have bought him.

But, as others have pointed out, we need homegrown players and he might yet turn out to be better than expected. If any team can prompt individuals to up their game, it has to be ours. He will be surrounded by world class talent and is young enough to grasp the opportunity if he does have the potential.
 
No-one wanted Delph prior to the window and even if he's a decent squad player no-one wanted us to sign more squad players.

But since it's likely to happen we, like any set of fans, are trying our best to make it a very good signing. Economically it might be but on the pitch is it?. Comparisons to Lescott and Barry, unfancied 'unsung' players, may be valid but they were also one of the main reasons we couldn't get out of the group stages of the CL. I like Lescott and Barry and am grateful for their efforts in winning domestic silverware, but as is the case with most English players, they found their level in the group stages.
 
No-one wanted Delph prior to the window and even if he's a decent squad player no-one wanted us to sign more squad players.

But since it's likely to happen we, like any set of fans, are trying our best to make it a very good signing. Economically it might be but on the pitch is it?. Comparisons to Lescott and Barry, unfancied 'unsung' players, may be valid but they were also one of the main reasons we couldn't get out of the group stages of the CL. I like Lescott and Barry and am grateful for their efforts in winning domestic silverware, but as is the case with most English players, they found their level in the group stages.

But just say Delph was brought in as a squad player so that the A listers could have a rest the weekend before a champions league game he could help us in Europe without playing that much.
 
Football is (or at least should be) meritocratic. There is a cycle, a food chain, and we are now at the top of it.

If an Italian player has 2 standout seasons in Serie A, Juventus will probably buy them. If a German does in the Bundesliga, more often than not Bayern will historically sign them. The Rags applied that formula to their benefit under Ferguson. It's the best policy to adopt where possible, because there is little chance that the pace/standard of the game in the respective country will effect them.

Without this opportunity, you'll never know how good a player is; Barry and Lescott were understated but crucial elements of our first wave of success. Neither had played for a top club before they joined us, but grabbed the opportunity with both hands, and to a lesser extent, so did Milner. By some of the derogatory logic on here applied to Delph, they'd never have been signed.

How many PL titles would Roy Keane have won if he'd stayed at Forest? Or Carrick at Spurs? Cahill at Bolton? How many Man Of The Match performances against top European opposition would Hart have had if he'd stayed at Birmingham after that sensational loan spell he had there in 09/10? None.

It's impossible to judge whether a player has top-class credentials until they've been given a fair chance to establish themselves at the highest level. Some take it, some don't, but someone like Delph is more worth of a place in the Manchester City squad based on his excellent performances in the Premier League over a sustained period than expensive failed imports like Anderson and Garcia.

This league is a tricky one, especially for a midfielder; the amusing failures of both Di Maria and Veron at Trafford's biggest club are testament to that. Both possessed world-class ability, and had years of elite-level football behind them but just simply couldn't get a grip of the game in the Premier League. There is a real possibility that Pogba would get found out in the same way, as both came with far better pedigree (the Serie A Veron played in was the best league in Europe at the time and infinitely better than the current one in which Pogba has shone, while Di Maria was MOTM in the CL final last year and a star of the World Cup) and if all of our midfield eggs are in that basket we are goosed.

This strange clause in the contract suggests that we have been in some form of contact with Delph since January; if so it's a very shrewd bit of business on the part of the club. Common sense, low risk/cost signing that could prove to be the shrewdest of any in the PL this summer.

Good post. The problem we've got here is that he'll be taking up Messi's place.
 
No-one wanted Delph prior to the window and even if he's a decent squad player no-one wanted us to sign more squad players.

But since it's likely to happen we, like any set of fans, are trying our best to make it a very good signing. Economically it might be but on the pitch is it?. Comparisons to Lescott and Barry, unfancied 'unsung' players, may be valid but they were also one of the main reasons we couldn't get out of the group stages of the CL. I like Lescott and Barry and am grateful for their efforts in winning domestic silverware, but as is the case with most English players, they found their level in the group stages.

Not sure you have grasped this football lark but it is now a necessity to have a decent squad of players to play in 4 competitions and we DO need the likes of Delph in there to help with all these games we will be playing.
 
But just say Delph was brought in as a squad player so that the A listers could have a rest the weekend before a champions league game he could help us in Europe without playing that much.

Couldn't Dinho have taken that role tho? Better to move a current start to backup. Dinho and Delph are very similar players as well so it makes no sense to have them both on the bench,
 
Not sure you have grasped this football lark but it is now a necessity to have a decent squad of players to play in 4 competitions and we DO need the likes of Delph in there to help with all these games we will be playing.

People always say this when we sign yet another squad player.
 
Not sure you have grasped this football lark but it is now a necessity to have a decent squad of players to play in 4 competitions and we DO need the likes of Delph in there to help with all these games we will be playing.

nahh they expect us to have a squad of 18 world class players
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.