- Joined
- 10 Nov 2024
- Messages
- 30
Going back to a few points again here. The "established club" argument is a bit of a weird one. Every club has a start. You can tell me if you have the same hatred towards Curzon Ashton. Were they needed in a town like Ashton that had long standing established clubs near them like Ashton Utd, Stalybridge Celtic and Mossley. A club that has relied massively on funding from Tameside Council, an area that's a lot more deprived than Manchester City Council. I mean we need to at least be consistent with the outrage.
The Ten Acres Lane issue is relevant. 10 years ago it was wasteland, today it's still wasteland. So it's not like that land was ear marked for anything else by developers or the council. So putting it there would have benefited the community better than the Broadhurst Park site. But that was a Manchester City Council decision based on pressure applied by Manchester City Football Club.
The relationship with Moston Juniors is being repaired, it's not perfect. There's local players who were there who've gone on to join the academy. You are right though in what you've said previously about the Academy, it is an education first centre, where people go to get a BTEC and play football. This isn't a novel idea that FC Utd capitalise on. Pretty much every non-league team, and some EFL teams offer the exact same programme. Halifax, Hyde, Oldham Athletic, Marine, Bradford Park Avenue, even Stockport County are just a few that do the same programme working with an external education company.
The club isn't hostile to City really. There is the odd song here and there that might reference City but the vast majoirty of the songs that are sung are about the club, and owning the club. There's probably as many anti-City songs that get sung on a matchday as there are at Oldham, Rochdale or Bury. The fanbase is changing as well, younger fans coming in who have never cared about Premier League football or City. The same question that is being asked about our identity could surely be asked about clubs like Maine Road couldn't they, or AFC Liverpool? Is there an issue with AFC Liverpool?
People donate what they can in different ways, some donate monthly on a direct debit, soome donate as and when they can. Does it matter what you get in return? If I watch City or United or West Ham and paid £600-700 a year for the last 20 years on a season ticket i'd have spent £12,000 -£14,000 of my own money, that's excluding travel etc. Have I got anything tangible for that? I'd have a load of memories, that's it, but I'm guessing nobody on here regrets spending £1000-2000 to go to Istanbul to watch a bunch of strangers who don't know you exist win the Champions League. The fans have a choice if they choose to donate. As it stands enough want to. Will that be the case in 20 years? Who knows, but 20 years ago most said the club would be gone by Christmas 2005, so chances are it will.
The relationship with Barrow will also help the club going forward. They've been struggling to find a purpose built football facility to train at and they know there's not many about. Salford City for example still haven't managed to sort one around Greater Manchester. That relationship with Barrow should also help the local community further as well.
If anything could be changed, maybe the club could have ground shared for longer. But that always comes with issues eventually.
The Ten Acres Lane issue is relevant. 10 years ago it was wasteland, today it's still wasteland. So it's not like that land was ear marked for anything else by developers or the council. So putting it there would have benefited the community better than the Broadhurst Park site. But that was a Manchester City Council decision based on pressure applied by Manchester City Football Club.
The relationship with Moston Juniors is being repaired, it's not perfect. There's local players who were there who've gone on to join the academy. You are right though in what you've said previously about the Academy, it is an education first centre, where people go to get a BTEC and play football. This isn't a novel idea that FC Utd capitalise on. Pretty much every non-league team, and some EFL teams offer the exact same programme. Halifax, Hyde, Oldham Athletic, Marine, Bradford Park Avenue, even Stockport County are just a few that do the same programme working with an external education company.
The club isn't hostile to City really. There is the odd song here and there that might reference City but the vast majoirty of the songs that are sung are about the club, and owning the club. There's probably as many anti-City songs that get sung on a matchday as there are at Oldham, Rochdale or Bury. The fanbase is changing as well, younger fans coming in who have never cared about Premier League football or City. The same question that is being asked about our identity could surely be asked about clubs like Maine Road couldn't they, or AFC Liverpool? Is there an issue with AFC Liverpool?
People donate what they can in different ways, some donate monthly on a direct debit, soome donate as and when they can. Does it matter what you get in return? If I watch City or United or West Ham and paid £600-700 a year for the last 20 years on a season ticket i'd have spent £12,000 -£14,000 of my own money, that's excluding travel etc. Have I got anything tangible for that? I'd have a load of memories, that's it, but I'm guessing nobody on here regrets spending £1000-2000 to go to Istanbul to watch a bunch of strangers who don't know you exist win the Champions League. The fans have a choice if they choose to donate. As it stands enough want to. Will that be the case in 20 years? Who knows, but 20 years ago most said the club would be gone by Christmas 2005, so chances are it will.
The relationship with Barrow will also help the club going forward. They've been struggling to find a purpose built football facility to train at and they know there's not many about. Salford City for example still haven't managed to sort one around Greater Manchester. That relationship with Barrow should also help the local community further as well.
If anything could be changed, maybe the club could have ground shared for longer. But that always comes with issues eventually.