OK - so my argument was based upon a TV news report from tonights C4 news - this was countered by your reference to a series of statistics in a posting gathered by Damocles who was disputing what was in tonights TV news report. It seems that report cannot be trusted " as it was just seen on the TV " but the sources of Damocles research is somehow beyond reproach?
Still doesn't alter a couple of facts though does it?
Which ever way you cut it - and thats even if you accept that the death rate amongst immigrant Indians in Qatar is on a percentage basis ( not in number ) comparable to that on all UK building sites that somehow means thats all fine and dandy. If a few immigrants die along the way then hey you can't make an omlette without breaking a few eggs eh? I still point to the fact that had it come to England we could point to a track record of bringing the other major world sporting event to this country, building the Olympic park and managing not to kill anybody in the process. Maybe our extra expenditure on Health and Safety meant we could only run to a watch as a "gift" to the delegates. I take it from your inference that a few hundred deaths in the great big scheme of things is an acceptable level?
Secondly - to get back to my original point which has been skillfully masked by diverting the argument - FIFA as an organisation is responsible in its bidding process to ensure that each country bidding includes things like budget, time to build, legacy and Health and Safety of construction workers, staff and participants in the tournament. I would say they have failed in number one lets see how they do on two and three. However given the onus is on them to at least accept a bid that won't result in worker deaths - or if it does to hold the successful bidders to account for the deaths - the failure of FIFA to do so reflects badly on its organisation and usually that means the guy at the top accepts the blame - Jesus even Fred the Shed and Bob Diamond left RBS and Barclays !!
We obviously won't agree but I still say that Sepp Blatter's re-election today is an indicator of all that is wrong with FIFA and that is being played out on the stage that is the Qatar World Cup - and may I remind you that Qatar put a bid in for the World Cup to run June -July 2022. They won against countries that also bid for that World Cup. They are going to hold the World Cup in Nov - Dec 2022 - that tournament was never put out to tender - that tournament was never the subject of any bids - those dates were never part of the tendering process.
And that will be my last word on the matter