Full Backs?

It is glaringly obvious that our archilles heel this year has been the full backs. Particularly at left back, both Kolarov and Clichy have really struggled and the in-balance within the team starts there followed by a competent defensive midfielder. I'm surprised Pep would risk his professional reputation by 'sticking when he most definately should twist' on a LB?
 
It is glaringly obvious that our archilles heel this year has been the full backs. Particularly at left back, both Kolarov and Clichy have really struggled and the in-balance within the team starts there followed by a competent defensive midfielder. I'm surprised Pep would risk his professional reputation by 'sticking when he most definately should twist' on a LB?

The other side of the coin with our last gold was that it earned some players long-term contracts, something which probably shouldn't have happened with the benefit of hindsight.

I do think that we have learned our lesson now, not letting a squad grow old together, and maybe shorter contracts and not as crazy salaries for players that could indeed be replaced.

I'm pretty sure that we, next summer, will see the real City for the future shape up, if we win a cup title and have a long run in Europe, at the same time we finish top 4, I'd be happy with the season.
 
I've always been impressed with Cedric at Southampton - good defensively and can get forward too, and probably wouldn't break the bank either.
 
I think going for the cheap option is what put us in this situation
Zabs and Sagna did fine for their low cost.

Kolorov wasn't cheap. The mistake we made with him was extending his contract instead of cutting our losses and letting him go.

Widening it out to defenders - Mangala and Otty weren't cheap and it's hard to say either have been value for money.

I'm hoping Stones will be.
 
Have we missed a trick not going for Van Aanholt? He's probably better than Clichy and Kolarov.
 
Zabs and Sagna did fine for their low cost.

Kolorov wasn't cheap. The mistake we made with him was extending his contract instead of cutting our losses and letting him go.

Widening it out to defenders - Mangala and Otty weren't cheap and it's hard to say either have been value for money.

I'm hoping Stones will be.
Otamendi actually has been value for money. But I agree we don't need expensive.

The problem here is that folks often mistake cost for talent. They are unrelated quite often. Cost often is a function of the player's hype and the doggedness of the owning club and league.

Players from Italy, are Portugal, overpriced and unreasonable, while players from Spain and Germany tend to be fairly priced. And players ft Netherland and France tend to be grossly underpriced.

If I was the Director of a midtable English club, you can easily close the gap on the top by bargain shopping in France and the Dutch leagues.

And if you are a smart top club you should get your role players from these leagues too.

So the question here is this? Who are the best fullbacks in the Netherlands and France? Figure who are rated in the top 6 fullbacks, then take the 2 that best fits your Philosophy.

Neither would cost more than 8 million. But we don't do this, instead we chase after overhyped players in the Italian and Portuguese leagues. This leagues profit by selling at exorbitant prices.

I mean, fucking Alderwierld, Wildnajnum, Erickson, Payet, Blind, Vertonghen, Vermaelen e.t.c. They almost all tend to cost less and give value.

Dutch league players a technically proficient, while French league players tend to be more aggressive.

Give me the best left back in the Dutch league and the best RB in the French league.

I bet you 15 million secured both with some change.
 
you can put the left sided center back in with the full backs as the 3 positions all have the same problem,
A. no first team player in his pomp
B. no young player in the b team desperate for a chance
C. now no youth player coming through
citys high back line and rotating have ruined citys defense with the help of age
a good defense is not bought or built it is grown , time playing together every week plays better than a defence of superstars rotated
so here is what i would buy
rb Karsdorp cheap young Walker play alike Iorfa cheap understudy
lcb Van Djik too late to get him cheap Hause cheap understudy.
lb Kolasinac out of contract in the summer Milner play alike, Sessegnon a must
non of these i would buy because they are cheap, but because they all have potential and time to grow
Dax777''s post above is spot on lets hope someone at city is listening, but after 3 years of these posts it is unlikely
 
Otamendi actually has been value for money. But I agree we don't need expensive.

The problem here is that folks often mistake cost for talent. They are unrelated quite often. Cost often is a function of the player's hype and the doggedness of the owning club and league.

Players from Italy, are Portugal, overpriced and unreasonable, while players from Spain and Germany tend to be fairly priced. And players ft Netherland and France tend to be grossly underpriced.

If I was the Director of a midtable English club, you can easily close the gap on the top by bargain shopping in France and the Dutch leagues.

And if you are a smart top club you should get your role players from these leagues too.

So the question here is this? Who are the best fullbacks in the Netherlands and France? Figure who are rated in the top 6 fullbacks, then take the 2 that best fits your Philosophy.

Neither would cost more than 8 million. But we don't do this, instead we chase after overhyped players in the Italian and Portuguese leagues. This leagues profit by selling at exorbitant prices.

I mean, fucking Alderwierld, Wildnajnum, Erickson, Payet, Blind, Vertonghen, Vermaelen e.t.c. They almost all tend to cost less and give value.

Dutch league players a technically proficient, while French league players tend to be more aggressive.

Give me the best left back in the Dutch league and the best RB in the French league.

I bet you 15 million secured both with some change.
Good post.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.