Futures of players out on loan

Pell said:
I would like to see Poveda get another loan spell at Leeds.
Click to expand...
We sold him mate,
"Leeds have not paid any money up front to sign the 19-year-old but could shell out up to £1m based on the number of appearances he makes. City will also get 30 per cent of a future sale"
 
decmancity said:
We sold him mate,
"Leeds have not paid any money up front to sign the 19-year-old but could shell out up to £1m based on the number of appearances he makes. City will also get 30 per cent of a future sale"
Click to expand...

Ah right, thanks for clearing that up.
 
Great update thanks. I still have hopes that Tosin can make the grade at City but think at this stage of his career he needs to play every week.

It is a shame that Anderlecht did not qualify for Europe as playing there, under VK's tutelage, in the Europa League would have been the ideal challenge for him.
 
Fantastic research and very interesting to read how they have all got on. I hope they all find decent clubs!

Let's be honest though, none of these players will play in the PL for us. They are there to be sold on for profit so we can spend it on the first team squad.
 
Psychedelic Casual said:
Well researched post.

Other than Steffen who may well be with us next season, I actually don’t think any of them will be City squad players. They’ll all go back out on loan or be sold.

I keep seeing people on this website saying that Tosin might be 3rd or 4th choice next season... there’s more chance of Fernandinho and Otamendi being given 5 year contracts and being our first choices for those five years than Tosin being a squad player for City. He’s a Championship level player, which is very good, it’s a good level of footy and easily in the top 20 leagues in Europe, but he won’t be playing for us.
Click to expand...

Championship is probably a top 5 league at least in terms of attendance if not quality top 20 is just daft
 
Bringing this back from the dead, May as well use this thread for the players out on loan this year....



I hope Nmecha can kick on this year, hes had a tough couple years.
 
Watched Girona v Real Mallorca the other evening, it was on in a bar. Pablo Moreno, on loan from City, scored what looked like a very smart, improvised backheel finish but it was ruled out by VAR for a push in the build up. Otherwise he looked useful but very small and lightweight.
You can see the incident here

Redirect Notice

www.google.co.uk
 
LongsightM13 said:
Watched Girona v Real Mallorca the other evening, it was on in a bar. Pablo Moreno, on loan from City, scored what looked like a very smart, improvised backheel finish but it was ruled out by VAR for a push in the build up. Otherwise he looked useful but very small and lightweight.
You can see the incident here

Redirect Notice

www.google.co.uk
Click to expand...
Pablo Moreno came on as sub for Girona at the weekend and scored their second in a 2-0 win at Albacete
Muric and Couto on the bench
 
LongsightM13 said:
Pablo Moreno came on as sub for Girona at the weekend and scored their second in a 2-0 win at Albacete
Muric and Couto on the bench
Click to expand...

The question that needs answering is would Muric have been better off just staying at City being on the bench and getting league cup games and being regarded as a decent prospect, training under Pep and the first team or moving on loan to Nottm Forest and then Girona and becoming the forgotten man.

It looks like two awful loans now and I am not sure any loan to Girona has been worth it for any of our players tbh.
 
bluealf said:
The question that needs answering is would Muric have been better off just staying at City being on the bench and getting league cup games and being regarded as a decent prospect, training under Pep and the first team or moving on loan to Nottm Forest and then Girona and becoming the forgotten man.

It looks like two awful loans now and I am not sure any loan to Girona has been worth it for any of our players tbh.
Click to expand...
Yep the Girona link up has been pretty disastrous for City. Pointless us sending lads there, it’s pretty much always a waste of a season
Contrast it to say RB Salzburg and Leipzig where there is a clear pathway
 
LongsightM13 said:
Yep the Girona link up has been pretty disastrous for City. Pointless us sending lads there, it’s pretty much always a waste of a season
Contrast it to say RB Salzburg and Leipzig where there is a clear pathway
Click to expand...
I fully agree and yet the Spanish link was meant to be the best, the Dutch ones have also been useful in a fashion, at least the lads played there.
 
bluealf said:
The question that needs answering is would Muric have been better off just staying at City being on the bench and getting league cup games and being regarded as a decent prospect, training under Pep and the first team or moving on loan to Nottm Forest and then Girona and becoming the forgotten man.

It looks like two awful loans now and I am not sure any loan to Girona has been worth it for any of our players tbh.
Click to expand...
I think the problem with Muric, is that Steffen is now number 2, so he is the one on the bench, and playing the cup games.
 
colesy said:
I think the problem with Muric, is that Steffen is now number 2, so he is the one on the bench, and playing the cup games.
Click to expand...
Kind of the point really, Muric went on loan 2 seasons on the trot, 3 seasons ago he was playing well in the league cup due to Bravo's injury, now he is further down the list and we have two or three younger keepers probably about to pass him by as well.
 
bluealf said:
Kind of the point really, Muric went on loan 2 seasons on the trot, 3 seasons ago he was playing well in the league cup due to Bravo's injury, now he is further down the list and we have two or three younger keepers probably about to pass him by as well.
Click to expand...

But the poster was suggesting he would be playing if he was here even if it was only cups truth is he would not

Also I suspect even if he had had some good loans we would still have bought Stefan Stefan would be number two playing in cups
 
WRicko said:
But the poster was suggesting he would be playing if he was here even if it was only cups truth is he would not

Also I suspect even if he had had some good loans we would still have bought Stefan Stefan would be number two playing in cups
Click to expand...
?

Either I am reading you wrong and I am confused by your post tbh?

I will try so forgive me if I haven't picked you up right.

I was the poster who mentioned Muric first, Colesy then said Steffan is now the number 2.


Now my original point was if Muric had stayed as the man in possession of the number 2 gloves as Bravo had or was about to leave would he have been better off than he is now.

His two loan spells have been a disaster and he has looked nothing like the keeper that played in our first team 3 seasons back.

If he had stayed and played like he did in the league cup then would we have needed to buy Steffan, nobody can say yes or no really tbh but what we can say is going out on loan has fucked Muric right over that is 100% fact.

He played at Forest and seemed to be doing okay but then made an error and then another they dropped him and that was pretty much it, 4 games in total.

He has played 2 for Girona and the older keeper has played 4.

I am not saying he is a star keeper and should be playing etc was just really saying our loan moves for some of these boys are fucking awful.

Other clubs send them out and they seem to get played all the time, you have to wonder if this is a stipulated condition of the loan?

As for Muric the kid has more Int caps than 1st class games but he is already more than likely done here.

Eddie
Steffan
Carson
Trafford
Bazuna, meant to be the next best thing is on loan at Rochdale but is playing
Slicker
Moulden
Mcnamara
Van Sas


These are vying for 3 places 1st team, EDS and Academy, mental really 10 keepers.

There might be more, I thought there was another on loan somewhere as well but the name has left the brain lol
 
Rightly, or wrongly (probably wrongly - I am rarely right about football matters), any player we sign who goes on loan isn't good enough. They are the football stiffs we sign who spend 2/3 years in low quality teams before we sell them on for a profit.

I've honestly lose all interest in any player who goes to Girona as that's the biggest stiff pit going. I'm sure a few players have come back better, but you've as much chance as winning the lottery as coming back from Girona and slipping into our first XI.

I totally understand why we do it - buy cheap and sell for a profit - but I do feel sorry for these young lads who get sent around Europe to sub-standard teams.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top