He was our second best player last year, at the very least. This year started very good, cooled a bit two months ago, but after being benched a couple times (and realising Aday is a good right back but lacks in attacking outlet in comparison) he is back to his best. I found him a player with a lot of energy, who can play in a very demanding position, being a player that has to defend as well as being a winger at the same time. I think he clearly improved his decision making in when to dribble, as well as his defensive duties, which are good. He could do practice a bit more passing, though.
Good enough to start in City? No, at least not now. Better than Danilo? Better than him playing at Madrid for sure.