Given or Hart

[blueonblue]

Yes it is a no brainer, Hart by a very long way.

Given has always had the same traits of freezing on the line, and failing to hold balls, he is is a good shot stopper and plays the angles well, but while he is good, Hart is better now with a lot more to come.

 

[Ederson1000YardDrive]

I was looking at the goals to games ratio between the two ,hardly any difference.
So are we getting worse in defence or is Hart as good as Given ?

Just the defense is wank

 

[ShaunyWrightWright]

Doesn't matter who is between the sticks with our god awful defense. Given has conceded a shite load and more than half he has had no chance of stopping.

Someone should strap some gloves on Dunne and see how he likes getting pelted.