Wonderful as the day was i thought the last Maine Rd Derby even better. The 5 1 was against a United side which at that point had won nothing under Ferguson in spite of massive spending. The last Maine Rd Derby was against an all conquering United side who were humiliated on and off the pitch. Neville reduced to tears after a major cock up and had to live with Gary Neville is a blue chant. If not my favourite game ever certainly in my top three, even now any win against the rags fills me with joy and keeps me happy for months.
Fair point, both games were great in their own ways, and being totally honest we probably thought we'd lose both!
Both were after long periods without a derby victory ,the last Maine Road one longer(although we'd obviously not played them every season in both cases).
The 5:1 was special because half our team had come through the youth system and United really had started to 'splash the cash' big time.
Looking back, I don't think they were a million miles ahead of us either in the last years of the old first division.
We should have definitely won the next 2 Maine Road derbies (well on top in both and cocked up a 3:1 lead then missed a last minute sitter) and we finished above them the following season. It was only really when the Premier League started that we really started going in different directions.
As you say in the last Maine Road Derby they were a much better side than in 89. so it was probably a more 'impressive(?)' victory for us. Winning the last Derby at Maine Road felt really important (as indeed was winning the first one at COMS the following season). It also felt at times previoys to this we'd never beat the rags again.
As you also say, all victories against the Rags are great, and even though we are, and have been better than them for sometime, I still certainly don't take them for granted!