Harry Maguire

Status
Not open for further replies.
BJL_City said:
well I think Koulibaly, Skriniar and Hernandez are all better for starters.
Click to expand...
Koulibally yes ( coz he plays in a similar system already and has exceptional ball skills). Skrinnier? maybe, he has looked Stellar this season.. Hernandez? You are having a laugh. There is no evidence outside of hype that he is better.
 
FantasyIreland said:
And given we bent them over regarding the Kelechi deal,they'll be keen to return the favour.

30m would be a fair price,i would guess 40m would be an asking price.
Click to expand...
The only downside to this is that it will be awfully expensive. Lecister will be looking for there Kele money back, plus about 20 mil for Harry.

You can expect starting bids around 45 million and up :(
 
Dax777 said:
I've been asking this question for months. But few ever choose to answer.

But I'm sure at some point the name Bonnuci will creep up again :/
Click to expand...

I'll hold my hand up and admit I do throw his name in on a regular basis, but he is the best centre half in Europe along with Chiellini.
 
BJL_City said:
well, if we exclude my eye:

Tackles Completed (P/G)

Umtiti - 2.4 (7)
Hernandez - 2.4 (7)
Skriniar - 2.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 2 (4)
Maguire - 1.7 (3)
Martinez - 1.3 (2)
Evans - 1.2 (1)

Tackle Success (%)

Umtiti - 85.7 (7)
Koulibaly - 83.3 (6)
Hernandez - 77.4 (5)
Skriniar - 74.2 (4)
Martinez - 72.2 (3)
Maguire - 70.8 (2)
Evans - 57.1 (1)


Dribbled Past (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (7)
Martinez - 0.5 (5)
Hernandez - 0.7 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (4)
Evans - 0.8 (2)
Skriniar - 0.8 (2)


Fouls Committed (P/G)

Maguire - 0.8 (7)
Martinez - 0.8 (7)
Umtiti - 0.9 (5)
Hernandez - 1 (4)
Koulibaly - 1 (4)
Evans - 1.1 (2)
Skriniar - 1.1 (2)

Interceptions (P/G)

Umtiti - 2 (7)
Evans - 1.8 (6)
Martinez - 1.6 (5)
Hernandez - 1.5 (4)
Koulibaly - 1.4 (3)
Maguire - 1.3 (2)
Skriniar - 1.2 (1)

Clearances (P/G)

Martinez - 5.2 (7)
Skriniar - 5.1 (6)
Maguire - 4.6 (5)
Evans - 4.2 (4)
Koulibaly - 3.5 (3)
Umtiti - 2.5 (2)
Hernandez - 2.3 (1)

Shots Blocked (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.8 (7)
Maguire - 0.7 (6)
Hernandez - 0.6 (5)
Skriniar - 0.6 (4)
Evans - 0.5 (3)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (2)
Martinez - 0.3 (1)

Passes Blocked (P/G)

Hernandez - 1 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.6 (6)
Martinez - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.3 (4)
Umtiti - 0.3 (4)
Evans - 0.2 (2)
Maguire - 0.2 (2)


Unsuccessful touches (P/G)

Martinez - 0.2 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.3 (6)
Evans - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.5 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (3)
Umtiti - 0.8 (2)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Dispossessed (P/G)

Koulibaly - 0.1 (7)
Umtiti - 0.1 (7)
Evans - 0.2 (5)
Martinez - 0.4 (4)
Maguire - 0.5 (3)
Skriniar - 0.5 (3)
Hernandez - 0.6 (1)

Headers Won (P/G)

Maguire - 3 (7)
Martinez - 2.4 (6)
Hernandez - 2.1 (5)
Evans - 1.9 (4)
Skriniar - 1.8 (3)
Umtiti - 1.7 (2)
Koulibaly - 1.6 (1)


Aerial Success (%)

Umtiti - 70.8 (7)
Skriniar - 64.3 (6)
Maguire - 60 (5)
Hernandez - 56.8 (4)
Martinez - 54.5 (3)
Evans - 54.3 (2)
Koulibaly - 53.3 (1)

Accurate Short Passes (P/G)

Koulibaly - 73.3 (7)
Umtiti - 67.1 (6)
Skriniar - 50.9 (5)
Martinez - 40.6 (4)
Maguire - 29.4 (3)
Hernandez - 27.7 (2)
Evans - 27.4 (1)


Short Passing Accuracy (%)

Skriniar - 94.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 94.1 (6)
Umtiti - 94.1 (6)
Hernandez - 87.9 (4)
Martinez - 87.3 (3)
Evans - 86.2 (2)
Maguire - 85.9 (1)

Accurate Long Passes (P/G)

Martinez - 4.7 (7)
Umtiti - 4.4 (6)
Maguire - 3.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 3.1 (4)
Skriniar - 2.9 (3)
Evans - 2.9 (3)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Long Passing Accuracy (%)

Umtiti - 69.8 (7)
Martinez - 61 (6)
Skriniar - 59.2 (5)
Evans - 50.9 (4)
Koulibaly - 50 (3)
Maguire - 43.4 (2)
Hernandez - 40 (1)

so Ranking score (ave):

Umtiti - 89 (5.56/7).
Martinez - 75 (4.69/7).
Koulibaly - 70 (4.38/7).
Skriniar - 64 (4/7).
Maguire - 60 (3.75/7).
Hernandez - 56 (3.5/7).
Evans - 47 (2.94/7).

So you can have Hernandez :)
Click to expand...
Your sample sizes are too small. Why are you not basing it off the total number of games they've played?

But going off that, you can see why interest in Umtiti is a no-brainer. But he plays for Barca, and unless he is unhappy, we ain't getting him.
 
Dax777 said:
The only downside to this is that it will be awfully expensive. Lecister will be looking for there Kele money back, plus about 20 mil for Harry.

You can expect starting bids around 45 million and up :(
Click to expand...
Never worth anything like that amount.

I guess we need to get more English players in?
 
BJL_City said:
well, if we exclude my eye:

Tackles Completed (P/G)

Umtiti - 2.4 (7)
Hernandez - 2.4 (7)
Skriniar - 2.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 2 (4)
Maguire - 1.7 (3)
Martinez - 1.3 (2)
Evans - 1.2 (1)

Tackle Success (%)

Umtiti - 85.7 (7)
Koulibaly - 83.3 (6)
Hernandez - 77.4 (5)
Skriniar - 74.2 (4)
Martinez - 72.2 (3)
Maguire - 70.8 (2)
Evans - 57.1 (1)


Dribbled Past (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (7)
Martinez - 0.5 (5)
Hernandez - 0.7 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (4)
Evans - 0.8 (2)
Skriniar - 0.8 (2)


Fouls Committed (P/G)

Maguire - 0.8 (7)
Martinez - 0.8 (7)
Umtiti - 0.9 (5)
Hernandez - 1 (4)
Koulibaly - 1 (4)
Evans - 1.1 (2)
Skriniar - 1.1 (2)

Interceptions (P/G)

Umtiti - 2 (7)
Evans - 1.8 (6)
Martinez - 1.6 (5)
Hernandez - 1.5 (4)
Koulibaly - 1.4 (3)
Maguire - 1.3 (2)
Skriniar - 1.2 (1)

Clearances (P/G)

Martinez - 5.2 (7)
Skriniar - 5.1 (6)
Maguire - 4.6 (5)
Evans - 4.2 (4)
Koulibaly - 3.5 (3)
Umtiti - 2.5 (2)
Hernandez - 2.3 (1)

Shots Blocked (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.8 (7)
Maguire - 0.7 (6)
Hernandez - 0.6 (5)
Skriniar - 0.6 (4)
Evans - 0.5 (3)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (2)
Martinez - 0.3 (1)

Passes Blocked (P/G)

Hernandez - 1 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.6 (6)
Martinez - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.3 (4)
Umtiti - 0.3 (4)
Evans - 0.2 (2)
Maguire - 0.2 (2)


Unsuccessful touches (P/G)

Martinez - 0.2 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.3 (6)
Evans - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.5 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (3)
Umtiti - 0.8 (2)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Dispossessed (P/G)

Koulibaly - 0.1 (7)
Umtiti - 0.1 (7)
Evans - 0.2 (5)
Martinez - 0.4 (4)
Maguire - 0.5 (3)
Skriniar - 0.5 (3)
Hernandez - 0.6 (1)

Headers Won (P/G)

Maguire - 3 (7)
Martinez - 2.4 (6)
Hernandez - 2.1 (5)
Evans - 1.9 (4)
Skriniar - 1.8 (3)
Umtiti - 1.7 (2)
Koulibaly - 1.6 (1)


Aerial Success (%)

Umtiti - 70.8 (7)
Skriniar - 64.3 (6)
Maguire - 60 (5)
Hernandez - 56.8 (4)
Martinez - 54.5 (3)
Evans - 54.3 (2)
Koulibaly - 53.3 (1)

Accurate Short Passes (P/G)

Koulibaly - 73.3 (7)
Umtiti - 67.1 (6)
Skriniar - 50.9 (5)
Martinez - 40.6 (4)
Maguire - 29.4 (3)
Hernandez - 27.7 (2)
Evans - 27.4 (1)


Short Passing Accuracy (%)

Skriniar - 94.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 94.1 (6)
Umtiti - 94.1 (6)
Hernandez - 87.9 (4)
Martinez - 87.3 (3)
Evans - 86.2 (2)
Maguire - 85.9 (1)

Accurate Long Passes (P/G)

Martinez - 4.7 (7)
Umtiti - 4.4 (6)
Maguire - 3.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 3.1 (4)
Skriniar - 2.9 (3)
Evans - 2.9 (3)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Long Passing Accuracy (%)

Umtiti - 69.8 (7)
Martinez - 61 (6)
Skriniar - 59.2 (5)
Evans - 50.9 (4)
Koulibaly - 50 (3)
Maguire - 43.4 (2)
Hernandez - 40 (1)

so Ranking score (ave):

Umtiti - 89 (5.56/7).
Martinez - 75 (4.69/7).
Koulibaly - 70 (4.38/7).
Skriniar - 64 (4/7).
Maguire - 60 (3.75/7).
Hernandez - 56 (3.5/7).
Evans - 47 (2.94/7).

So you can have Hernandez :)
Click to expand...
See. Like I thought, Hernandez us still all hype :) Btw can you add Bonucci to get he mix. Let folks see his averageness :)
 
Bilboblue said:
Never worth anything like that amount.

I guess we need to get more English players in?
Click to expand...
Don't know. With a 75 million defender paid for, 50 becomes the new normal. :( Fucking Liverpool! Messing up the blood market
 
PW said:
I'll hold my hand up and admit I do throw his name in on a regular basis, but he is the best centre half in Europe along with Chiellini.
Click to expand...
I think he is mostly hype. Good (not great) ball playing CB. Other than that he is ok. His hype as the best CB skyrocketed coz Pep once gushed over him prior to a game against Juve. And from then on everyone bought the koolaide and never reevaluated him. Before that gushing, most thought of him simply as a good defender who played nex to Chielini.

Btw, he isn't dominating now at Milan. Which in fairness is normal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.