Harry Maguire

[aguero93:20]

well, if we exclude my eye:

Tackles Completed (P/G)

Umtiti - 2.4 (7)
Hernandez - 2.4 (7)
Skriniar - 2.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 2 (4)
Maguire - 1.7 (3)
Martinez - 1.3 (2)
Evans - 1.2 (1)

Tackle Success (%)

Umtiti - 85.7 (7)
Koulibaly - 83.3 (6)
Hernandez - 77.4 (5)
Skriniar - 74.2 (4)
Martinez - 72.2 (3)
Maguire - 70.8 (2)
Evans - 57.1 (1)


Dribbled Past (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (7)
Martinez - 0.5 (5)
Hernandez - 0.7 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (4)
Evans - 0.8 (2)
Skriniar - 0.8 (2)


Fouls Committed (P/G)

Maguire - 0.8 (7)
Martinez - 0.8 (7)
Umtiti - 0.9 (5)
Hernandez - 1 (4)
Koulibaly - 1 (4)
Evans - 1.1 (2)
Skriniar - 1.1 (2)

Interceptions (P/G)

Umtiti - 2 (7)
Evans - 1.8 (6)
Martinez - 1.6 (5)
Hernandez - 1.5 (4)
Koulibaly - 1.4 (3)
Maguire - 1.3 (2)
Skriniar - 1.2 (1)

Clearances (P/G)

Martinez - 5.2 (7)
Skriniar - 5.1 (6)
Maguire - 4.6 (5)
Evans - 4.2 (4)
Koulibaly - 3.5 (3)
Umtiti - 2.5 (2)
Hernandez - 2.3 (1)

Shots Blocked (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.8 (7)
Maguire - 0.7 (6)
Hernandez - 0.6 (5)
Skriniar - 0.6 (4)
Evans - 0.5 (3)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (2)
Martinez - 0.3 (1)

Passes Blocked (P/G)

Hernandez - 1 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.6 (6)
Martinez - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.3 (4)
Umtiti - 0.3 (4)
Evans - 0.2 (2)
Maguire - 0.2 (2)


Unsuccessful touches (P/G)

Martinez - 0.2 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.3 (6)
Evans - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.5 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (3)
Umtiti - 0.8 (2)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Dispossessed (P/G)

Koulibaly - 0.1 (7)
Umtiti - 0.1 (7)
Evans - 0.2 (5)
Martinez - 0.4 (4)
Maguire - 0.5 (3)
Skriniar - 0.5 (3)
Hernandez - 0.6 (1)

Headers Won (P/G)

Maguire - 3 (7)
Martinez - 2.4 (6)
Hernandez - 2.1 (5)
Evans - 1.9 (4)
Skriniar - 1.8 (3)
Umtiti - 1.7 (2)
Koulibaly - 1.6 (1)


Aerial Success (%)

Umtiti - 70.8 (7)
Skriniar - 64.3 (6)
Maguire - 60 (5)
Hernandez - 56.8 (4)
Martinez - 54.5 (3)
Evans - 54.3 (2)
Koulibaly - 53.3 (1)

Accurate Short Passes (P/G)

Koulibaly - 73.3 (7)
Umtiti - 67.1 (6)
Skriniar - 50.9 (5)
Martinez - 40.6 (4)
Maguire - 29.4 (3)
Hernandez - 27.7 (2)
Evans - 27.4 (1)


Short Passing Accuracy (%)

Skriniar - 94.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 94.1 (6)
Umtiti - 94.1 (6)
Hernandez - 87.9 (4)
Martinez - 87.3 (3)
Evans - 86.2 (2)
Maguire - 85.9 (1)

Accurate Long Passes (P/G)

Martinez - 4.7 (7)
Umtiti - 4.4 (6)
Maguire - 3.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 3.1 (4)
Skriniar - 2.9 (3)
Evans - 2.9 (3)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Long Passing Accuracy (%)

Umtiti - 69.8 (7)
Martinez - 61 (6)
Skriniar - 59.2 (5)
Evans - 50.9 (4)
Koulibaly - 50 (3)
Maguire - 43.4 (2)
Hernandez - 40 (1)

so Ranking score (ave):

Umtiti - 89 (5.56/7).
Martinez - 75 (4.69/7).
Koulibaly - 70 (4.38/7).
Skriniar - 64 (4/7).
Maguire - 60 (3.75/7).
Hernandez - 56 (3.5/7).
Evans - 47 (2.94/7).

So you can have Hernandez :)

So, basically, Evans is shit?

 

[domalino]

well, if we exclude my eye:

Tackles Completed (P/G)

Umtiti - 2.4 (7)
Hernandez - 2.4 (7)
Skriniar - 2.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 2 (4)
Maguire - 1.7 (3)
Martinez - 1.3 (2)
Evans - 1.2 (1)

Tackle Success (%)

Umtiti - 85.7 (7)
Koulibaly - 83.3 (6)
Hernandez - 77.4 (5)
Skriniar - 74.2 (4)
Martinez - 72.2 (3)
Maguire - 70.8 (2)
Evans - 57.1 (1)


Dribbled Past (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (7)
Martinez - 0.5 (5)
Hernandez - 0.7 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (4)
Evans - 0.8 (2)
Skriniar - 0.8 (2)


Fouls Committed (P/G)

Maguire - 0.8 (7)
Martinez - 0.8 (7)
Umtiti - 0.9 (5)
Hernandez - 1 (4)
Koulibaly - 1 (4)
Evans - 1.1 (2)
Skriniar - 1.1 (2)

Interceptions (P/G)

Umtiti - 2 (7)
Evans - 1.8 (6)
Martinez - 1.6 (5)
Hernandez - 1.5 (4)
Koulibaly - 1.4 (3)
Maguire - 1.3 (2)
Skriniar - 1.2 (1)

Clearances (P/G)

Martinez - 5.2 (7)
Skriniar - 5.1 (6)
Maguire - 4.6 (5)
Evans - 4.2 (4)
Koulibaly - 3.5 (3)
Umtiti - 2.5 (2)
Hernandez - 2.3 (1)

Shots Blocked (P/G)

Umtiti - 0.8 (7)
Maguire - 0.7 (6)
Hernandez - 0.6 (5)
Skriniar - 0.6 (4)
Evans - 0.5 (3)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (2)
Martinez - 0.3 (1)

Passes Blocked (P/G)

Hernandez - 1 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.6 (6)
Martinez - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.3 (4)
Umtiti - 0.3 (4)
Evans - 0.2 (2)
Maguire - 0.2 (2)


Unsuccessful touches (P/G)

Martinez - 0.2 (7)
Koulibaly - 0.3 (6)
Evans - 0.4 (5)
Skriniar - 0.5 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (3)
Umtiti - 0.8 (2)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Dispossessed (P/G)

Koulibaly - 0.1 (7)
Umtiti - 0.1 (7)
Evans - 0.2 (5)
Martinez - 0.4 (4)
Maguire - 0.5 (3)
Skriniar - 0.5 (3)
Hernandez - 0.6 (1)

Headers Won (P/G)

Maguire - 3 (7)
Martinez - 2.4 (6)
Hernandez - 2.1 (5)
Evans - 1.9 (4)
Skriniar - 1.8 (3)
Umtiti - 1.7 (2)
Koulibaly - 1.6 (1)


Aerial Success (%)

Umtiti - 70.8 (7)
Skriniar - 64.3 (6)
Maguire - 60 (5)
Hernandez - 56.8 (4)
Martinez - 54.5 (3)
Evans - 54.3 (2)
Koulibaly - 53.3 (1)

Accurate Short Passes (P/G)

Koulibaly - 73.3 (7)
Umtiti - 67.1 (6)
Skriniar - 50.9 (5)
Martinez - 40.6 (4)
Maguire - 29.4 (3)
Hernandez - 27.7 (2)
Evans - 27.4 (1)


Short Passing Accuracy (%)

Skriniar - 94.4 (7)
Koulibaly - 94.1 (6)
Umtiti - 94.1 (6)
Hernandez - 87.9 (4)
Martinez - 87.3 (3)
Evans - 86.2 (2)
Maguire - 85.9 (1)

Accurate Long Passes (P/G)

Martinez - 4.7 (7)
Umtiti - 4.4 (6)
Maguire - 3.3 (5)
Koulibaly - 3.1 (4)
Skriniar - 2.9 (3)
Evans - 2.9 (3)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Long Passing Accuracy (%)

Umtiti - 69.8 (7)
Martinez - 61 (6)
Skriniar - 59.2 (5)
Evans - 50.9 (4)
Koulibaly - 50 (3)
Maguire - 43.4 (2)
Hernandez - 40 (1)

so Ranking score (ave):

Umtiti - 89 (5.56/7).
Martinez - 75 (4.69/7).
Koulibaly - 70 (4.38/7).
Skriniar - 64 (4/7).
Maguire - 60 (3.75/7).
Hernandez - 56 (3.5/7).
Evans - 47 (2.94/7).

So you can have Hernandez :)

Add in Stones & Otamendi

 

[PannickAtTheDisco]

Add in Stones & Otamendi

anyone else? might as well do it all in one go this afternoon...

 

[domalino]

anyone else? might as well do it all in one go this afternoon...

Well to be honest it's never going to prove anything either way so I wouldn't waste you time. Maguire winning more headers per game doesn't make him a better defender than anyone else, and him having lower pass accuracy in a team who play "knock it long for Vardy" doesn't make him worse.

Leicester are shit and don't play a possession based system so why compare Maguire's total number of passes to someone like Umtiti or Koulibaly? What's the aim there?

 

[PannickAtTheDisco]

Well to be honest it's never going to prove anything either way so I wouldn't waste you time. Maguire winning more headers per game doesn't make him a better defender than anyone else, and him having lower pass accuracy in a team who play "knock it long for Vardy" doesn't make him worse.

Leicester are shit and don't play a possession based system so why compare Maguire's total number of passes to someone like Umtiti or Koulibaly? What's the aim there?

his pass accuracy is still lower on short passes despite having to make fewer, it's reflective of what style of play he's used to which is relevant when coming to play for us. If you have to jump from 27 passes to 65/70 then you need to have that skill-set about you. If I ignored his heading abilities people would just accuse me of cherry-picking. Also, it shows that although he has more to do aerially he's not as dominant as someone like Umtiti, who playing for Barca you may expect to be less inclined to dominate those aspects.

 

[pudge]

I don't rate him that highly but if the club do want him then a move for Evans this January makes even less sense.

 

[NQCitizen]

I don't think these stats actually make Maguire look that bad.

He's not as good as Koulibaly or Umtiti, which is obvious anyway but he is potentially the best genuinely available centre back.

 

[Bluemanc100]

Not a fan but in Josep we trust...

 

[PannickAtTheDisco]

Updated to include Otamendi, Stones, van Dijk and Christensen. I've also updated Martinez and Evans as I did them a few weeks ago and realised I'd used a couple of Inigo's Europa League stats rather than La Liga stats. Some perhaps surprising stats for the City lads but shows what Pep's looking for, so you can compare directly in categories where they are strongest as that relates best to what Pep's looking for:

Tackles Completed (P/G)

Umtiti - 2.4 (11)
Hernandez - 2.4 (11)
Skriniar - 2.3 (9)
Koulibaly - 2 (8)
Maguire - 1.7 (7)
Otamendi - 1.6 (6)
Christensen - 1.2 (5)
Martinez - 1.2 (5)
Stones - 1.2 (5)
Evans - 1.1 (2)
van Dijk - 0.8 (1)

Tackle Success (%)

Christensen - 92.3 (11)
van Dijk - 88.8 (10)
Umtiti - 85.7 (9)
Koulibaly - 83.3 (8)
Hernandez - 77.4 (7)
Skriniar - 74.2 (6)
Maguire - 70.8 (5)
Martinez - 70.6 (4)
Stones - 70.6 (4)
Otamendi - 69.6 (2)
Evans - 57.1 (1)

Dribbled Past (P/G)

Christensen - 0.1 (11)
van Dijk - 0.1 (11)
Umtiti - 0.4 (9)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (9)
Martinez - 0.5 (7)
Stones - 0.5 (7)
Hernandez - 0.7 (5)
Maguire - 0.7 (5)
Otamendi - 0.7 (5)
Evans - 0.8 (2)
Skriniar - 0.8 (2)

Fouls Committed (P/G)

Christensen - 0.3 (11)
Stones - 0.4 (10)
van Dijk - 0.5 (9)
Otamendi - 0.7 (8)
Maguire - 0.8 (7)
Martinez - 0.8 (7)
Umtiti - 0.9 (5)
Hernandez - 1 (4)
Koulibaly - 1 (4)
Evans - 1 (4)
Skriniar - 1.1 (1)

Interceptions (P/G)

van Dijk - 2.4 (11)
Umtiti - 2 (10)
Evans - 1.7 (9)
Otamendi - 1.7 (9)
Martinez - 1.6 (7)
Hernandez - 1.5 (6)
Koulibaly - 1.4 (5)
Christensen - 1.3 (4)
Maguire - 1.3 (4)
Skriniar - 1.2 (2)
Stones - 1.2 (2)

Clearances (P/G)

van Dijk - 6.5 (11)
Skriniar - 5.1 (10)
Martinez - 4.8 (9)
Maguire - 4.6 (8)
Evans - 3.9 (7)
Christensen - 3.6 (6)
Koulibaly - 3.5 (5)
Otamendi - 3.4 (4)
Umtiti - 2.5 (3)
Hernandez - 2.3 (2)
Stones - 2.1 (1)

Shots Blocked (P/G)

van Dijk - 1.1 (11)
Umtiti - 0.8 (10)
Maguire - 0.7 (9)
Hernandez - 0.6 (8)
Skriniar - 0.6 (8)
Evans - 0.4 (6)
Koulibaly - 0.4 (6)
Martinez - 0.4 (6)
Christensen - 0.3 (3)
Otamendi - 0.3 (3)
Stones - 0.3 (3)

Passes Blocked (P/G)

Hernandez - 1 (11)
Koulibaly - 0.6 (10)
Christensen - 0.5 (9)
Martinez - 0.4 (8)
Skriniar - 0.3 (7)
Umtiti - 0.3 (7)
Evans - 0.2 (5)
Maguire - 0.2 (5)
Otamendi - 0.2 (5)
Stones - 0.2 (5)
van Dijk - 0.1 (1)

Unsuccessful touches (P/G)

Martinez - 0.2 (11)
Koulibaly - 0.3 (10)
Christensen - 0.3 (9)
Stones - 0.3 (9)
van Dijk - 0.3 (9)
Evans - 0.4 (6)
Skriniar - 0.5 (5)
Otamendi - 0.6 (4)
Maguire - 0.7 (3)
Umtiti - 0.8 (2)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Dispossessed (P/G)

Otamendi - 0 (11)
Koulibaly - 0.1 (10)
Christensen - 0.1 (10)
Umtiti - 0.1 (10)
Evans - 0.2 (7)
van Dijk - 0.3 (6)
Martinez - 0.4 (5)
Stones - 0.4 (5)
Maguire - 0.5 (3)
Skriniar - 0.5 (3)
Hernandez - 0.6 (1)

Headers Won (P/G)

van Dijk - 5 (11)
Maguire - 3 (10)
Otamendi - 2.8 (9)
Christensen - 2.5 (8)
Martinez - 2.4 (7)
Hernandez - 2.1 (6)
Evans - 1.8 (5)
Skriniar - 1.8 (5)
Umtiti - 1.7 (3)
Koulibaly - 1.6 (2)
Stones - 1.5 (1)

Aerial Success (%)

Stones - 78.9 (11)
van Dijk - 73.5 (10)
Umtiti - 70.8 (9)
Skriniar - 64.3 (8)
Christensen - 60 (7)
Maguire - 60 (7)
Otamendi - 58.3 (5)
Hernandez - 56.8 (4)
Martinez - 55.8 (3)
Koulibaly - 53.3 (2)
Evans - 52.9 (1)

Accurate Short Passes (P/G)

Otamendi - 81 (11)
Koulibaly - 73.3 (10)
Umtiti - 67.1 (9)
Stones - 65.3 (8)
Skriniar - 50.9 (7)
Christensen - 42.3 (6)
van Dijk - 42.3 (6)
Martinez - 40.9 (4)
Maguire - 29.4 (3)
Hernandez - 27.7 (2)
Evans - 26.8 (1)

Short Passing Accuracy (%)

Stones - 98.2 (11)
Christensen - 94.8 (10)
Skriniar - 94.4 (9)
Koulibaly - 94.1 (8)
Umtiti - 94.1 (8)
Otamendi - 94 (6)
van Dijk - 92.4 (5)
Hernandez - 87.9 (4)
Martinez - 87.6 (3)
Evans - 86.2 (2)
Maguire - 85.9 (1)

Accurate Long Passes (P/G)

Martinez - 5.2 (11)
Umtiti - 4.4 (10)
Otamendi - 4 (9)
Maguire - 3.3 (8)
Evans - 3.1 (7)
Koulibaly - 3.1 (7)
van Dijk - 3 (5)
Skriniar - 2.9 (4)
Stones - 2.9 (4)
Christensen - 2.7 (2)
Hernandez - 1 (1)

Long Passing Accuracy (%)

Christensen - 79.4 (11)
Stones - 70.7 (10)
Umtiti - 69.8 (9)
Otamendi - 66.7 (8)
Skriniar - 59.2 (7)
Evans - 53.4 (6)
Koulibaly - 50 (5)
Martinez - 45.2 (4)
Maguire - 43.4 (3)
van Dijk - 42.9 (2)
Hernandez - 40 (1)

so Ranking score (ave):

Christensen - 124 (7.75/11)
Umtiti - 124 (7.75/11)
van Dijk - 120 (7.50/11)
Koulibaly - 109 (6.81/11)
Otamendi - 105 (6.56/11)
Martinez - 101 (6.31/11)
Stones - 95 (5.94/11)
Skriniar - 93 (5.81/11)
Maguire - 88 (5.50/11)
Hernandez - 74 (4.63/11)
Evans - 71 (4.44/11)

The ranking obviously puts more weight on defensive work, so what's more interesting is where the other players relate to Ota and Stones in each category. From looking at it, I think Umtiti is in a class of his own out of our potential targets, breaking it down by our lads key strengths in our system:

Long Passing Accuracy (%): Christensen - 79.4 (11), Stones - 70.7 (10), Umtiti - 69.8 (9), Otamendi - 66.7 (8), Skriniar - 59.2 (7), Evans - 53.4 (6), Koulibaly - 50 (5).
Short Passing Accuracy (%): Stones - 98.2 (11), Christensen - 94.8 (10), Skriniar - 94.4 (9), Koulibaly - 94.1 (8), Umtiti - 94.1 (8), Otamendi - 94 (6), van Dijk - 92.4 (5).
Accurate Short Passes (P/G): Otamendi - 81 (11), Koulibaly - 73.3 (10), Umtiti - 67.1 (9), Stones - 65.3 (8), Skriniar - 50.9 (7), Christensen - 42.3 (6), van Dijk - 42.3 (6).
Aerial Success (%): Stones - 78.9 (11), van Dijk - 73.5 (10), Umtiti - 70.8 (9), Skriniar - 64.3 (8), Christensen - 60 (7), Maguire - 60 (7), Otamendi - 58.3 (5).
Dispossessed (P/G): Otamendi - 0 (11), Koulibaly - 0.1 (10), Christensen - 0.1 (10), Umtiti - 0.1 (10), Evans - 0.2 (7), van Dijk - 0.3 (6), Martinez - 0.4 (5), Stones - 0.4 (5).
Fouls Committed (P/G): Christensen - 0.3 (11), Stones - 0.4 (10), van Dijk - 0.5 (9), Otamendi - 0.7 (8), Maguire - 0.8 (7), Martinez - 0.8 (7),Umtiti - 0.9 (5).

Same names pop up most of the time. It's much more about our possession, range of passing, winning headers when needed and not giving away fouls rather than tackling people.

 

[Dax777]

I really like this guy.

Needs to drop the body fat but he impressed me in his first game of the season at Arsenal.

Very composed, a more aggressive and heftier Stones.

Don't know why so many don't see it. But he is a lot like a bigger John Stone. Probably better at driving the ball forward too.