PannickAtTheDisco
Well-Known Member
no, I've had enough now.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Harry Maguire
- Thread starter ste.sully
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
no, I've had enough now.
PannickAtTheDisco
Well-Known Member
Your sample sizes are too small. Why are you not basing it off the total number of games they've played?
But going off that, you can see why interest in Umtiti is a no-brainer. But he plays for Barca, and unless he is unhappy, we ain't getting him.
because if you base it on total number of games, players who have played more will have done more, I'm more interested in actions per game as that gives a better indicator of their role compared to what Pep wants. Seeing as we're buying a CB now, I think this season's stats are most relevant.
That was an error on my part. I thought your rankings were number of games by the players.because if you base it on total number of games, players who have played more will have done more, I'm more interested in actions per game as that gives a better indicator of their role compared to what Pep wants. Seeing as we're buying a CB now, I think this season's stats are most relevant.
The top being 7 ( meaning highest) and the bottom (1 or 2) meaning lowest.
At first I wondered why you were using 7 games for some players and 2 for others. Then I realized it was the rankings :)
Tbilisi
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 5 Jul 2009
- Messages
- 8,405
- Team supported
- City and Darlington FC
England should want this to happen aswell, them two at the back for city would be England’s centre back partnership for years to come!
Pep saves English football too lol
PannickAtTheDisco
Well-Known Member
That was an error on my part. I thought your rankings were number of games by the players.
The top being 7 ( meaning highest) and the bottom (1 or 2) meaning lowest.
At first I wondered why you were using 7 games for some players and 2 for others. Then I realized it was the rankings :)
yeah, was just a crude rank where the person with the best stats got the most points and vice-versa. Gives each stat equal weighting where percentages wouldn't, more interested in the comparison in where our players are strongest.
I must read too many stats coz outside of Christiansen who I'd never evaluated, Koulibally and VVD were pretty much the only CBs i considered superior to what we had. And your stats seem to back that up too.yeah, was just a crude rank where the person with the best stats got the most points and vice-versa. Gives each stat equal weighting where percentages wouldn't, more interested in the comparison in where our players are strongest.
In fairness I didn't realize how good Umtiti was. New he was top class, but didn't realize he was this exceptional.
PannickAtTheDisco
Well-Known Member
I must read too many stats coz outside of Christiansen who I'd never evaluated, Koulibally and VVD were pretty much the only CBs i considered superior to what we had. And your stats seem to back that up too.
In fairness I didn't realize how good Umtiti was. New he was top class, but didn't realize he was this exceptional.
Yh, Christensen makes me wish Mou was still in charge of Chelsea, because he'd have sold him to Gladbach and we could buy him ;(.
So based on the numbers here it looks like outside of the guys we can't get:
VVD, Umtiti, Christainsen and Koulibally (he might be gettable in the summer)
The best prosepects 1) Martinez 2) Skrinnier 3) Maguire
Btw, what site do you use? Most sites I use only let me compare 5 players at a time. And I end up doing a mental ranking.
I'd like to add some players. But I don't want to mention names as they are highly unrated here. And I suspect they are better than they get credit for :)
VVD, Umtiti, Christainsen and Koulibally (he might be gettable in the summer)
The best prosepects 1) Martinez 2) Skrinnier 3) Maguire
I know right.Yh, Christensen makes me wish Mou was still in charge of Chelsea, because he'd have sold him to Gladbach and we could buy him ;(.
Btw, what site do you use? Most sites I use only let me compare 5 players at a time. And I end up doing a mental ranking.
I'd like to add some players. But I don't want to mention names as they are highly unrated here. And I suspect they are better than they get credit for :)
PannickAtTheDisco
Well-Known Member
So based on the numbers here it looks like outside of the guys we can't get:
VVD, Umtiti, Christainsen and Koulibally (he might be gettable in the summer)
The best prosepects 1) Martinez 2) Skrinnier 3) Maguire
I know right.
Btw, what site do you use? Most sites I use only let me compare 5 players at a time. And I end up doing a mental ranking.
I'd like to add some players. But I don't want to mention names as they are highly unrated here. And I suspect they are better than they get credit for :)
used whoscored, then popped it in a spreadsheet.
I see. That's why it looks different. You added some nice touch :)used whoscored, then popped it in a spreadsheet.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.