How would you assess Rodri's season?

So you knew what we were getting?

What were we getting?

This probably says it all;
"He will need a period of adaptation to get to the rhythm of the Premier League. Even though he’s a player tailor-made for Pep’s system, it’s going to take a lot of work on his part to get the hang of that highly specialized role. "
 
He has one fundamental flaw that will always be exposed in a Guardiola team. His pace. If you cant cover the ground, then playing as a single pivot means you'll always be exposed on the break.
Pep must of knew this though ? He was after jorginho aswell the season before , who is a similar player not blessed with pace .
I would have thought in his system with the two attacking mids and one defensive one , you need pace as you’ve got so much ground to cover .
Pep doesn’t seem to want that type of player for that position though , Fernandinho may have been the exception.
 

This probably says it all;
"He will need a period of adaptation to get to the rhythm of the Premier League. Even though he’s a player tailor-made for Pep’s system, it’s going to take a lot of work on his part to get the hang of that highly specialized role. "

I stopped reading when it claimed he has "pace".

I gave it the benefit of the doubt and went back again but stopped reading when it used the word "majestic" to describe him.

So, you read this clearly ridiculous piece and "knew what we were getting"? Did you ever actually watch the lad play?
 
I stopped reading when it claimed he has "pace".

I gave it the benefit of the doubt and went back again but stopped reading when it used the word "majestic" to describe him.

So, you read this clearly ridiculous piece and "knew what we were getting"? Did you ever actually watch the lad play?
Yeah, I watched Atletico quite a lot. To be fair, I wanted us to sign Koke or Partey but it was clear to see that Rodri was a good player.

I cba typing up a full report so I found that and it describes him as a player pretty perfectly.

Lets just leave it there because clearly you have your own opinion and are posting it across the forum every day so ill leave you to it. Rodri is here, and he will be starting next season so lets hope he magically grows and becomes this game winning player you for some reason think he needs to be.
 
They wouldn't buy him because he's shit.

He doesn't fit into our team either.

Record fee midfield players should be absolutely outstanding, able to run games and able to provide game winning moments consistently.

Toure, De Bruyne, Silva levels of ability.

This lad is absolutely nowhere near.

If we were to transfer list him today do you think Europe's top clubs would be falling over themselves to sign him?

Would they fuck and that says it all.

Do you think other teams see him on the team sheet and think "that's us fucked today"?

That is just nonsense, he is a holding midfielder he isnt expected to provide game winning moments. comparing him with Yaya, Silva and De Bruyne is laughable.

An has a team ever looked at a holding midfielder (or any defensive player) and thought "that's us fucked today"? Obviously not as you only worry about the people who are going to score or assist against you.
 
They wouldn't buy him because he's shit.

He doesn't fit into our team either.

Record fee midfield players should be absolutely outstanding, able to run games and able to provide game winning moments consistently.

Toure, De Bruyne, Silva levels of ability.

This lad is absolutely nowhere near.

If we were to transfer list him today do you think Europe's top clubs would be falling over themselves to sign him?

Would they fuck and that says it all.

Do you think other teams see him on the team sheet and think "that's us fucked today"?
One game and suddenly our players are all shit.

The difference between Silva, Yaya and KDB is that they played together. Toure had Silva at his best alongside him.

If Rodri had 2 runners alongside him we wouldn't have a problem. You don't need the mobility if you have 2 players willing to run- in a fluid system. You cannot judge him off a game where 3 defensive midfielders have played and De Bruyne played as a number 6? That's completely down to Pep, and nobody else. Barcelona won titles year after year with Busquets in the middle. Busquets wasn't the most mobile but he had players around him willing to run. Your comparison is based on comparing him to Fernandinho which I think is completely unfair. There aren't many Fernandinhos about who could run, break play up and dictate a game at the same time.

The likes of Xabi Alonso and Busquets weren't Fernandinho either. You don't need to be mobile to break play up. Put Rodri in the Bayern team and I'm sure he'd be brilliant. Barry/Makelele didn't need to run they just mopped everything up and had runners around them.

The games Rodri has looked poor in is the games against teams where we've had Rodri, Gundogan and De Bruyne as a 3. That simply doesn't work. Playing Gundogan and Rodri alongside each other does not work. You've got to put players alongside him who are willing to run like Bernardo, foden and KDB.

Take a look at Liverpool for example. Without Henderson and Wijnaldum running for Fabinho he wouldn't look anywhere near as good as he does. Take those two players out of that system and he would look exposed. Put 2 pretty footballers in there who are static and have no defensive capabilities and he'd struggle. I wouldn't have Henderson or Wijnaldum at City but they are willing to run through midfields and chase the ball 30 yards forwards and back to support their defence.

Rodri is a quality player, but he's been used so wrongly by Pep. Against Liverpool at home he was fantastic because he had Foden and De Bruyne doing the running for him. He mopped everything up and separated defence to attack superbly. Either we play Gundogan there or Rodri there. You cannot have both.
 
Last edited:
Good, with plenty of potential to get better. I think ultimately everyone who signed him recognised that he really would need a season to settle in and play on his own in that position, and not having a consistent back four, outside of Walker, behind him has really hurt him.
 
From a slower based league albeit Atlético play an energetic game. Adapting to PL easier from Ligue 1 or Bundesliga than Serie A or La Liga - such a CDM needs time and a faster defence in behind. His second season will be better but afraid to call by how much?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.