You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Hughes - Update
- Thread starter scorer
- Start date
City Soul Boy
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 May 2009
- Messages
- 401
If this is what its like when we are doing well whats it going to be like if we it a bad patch !
moomba said:levets said:You don't get off that easily... in our previous discussions I suggested that you hated Hughes because of his background, ie playing for united. You told me that it had nothing to do with this and you didn't want him here because....... 'he is a horrible person'.. or words to that effect. Did you not? I suggest he should be judged on his ability to do his job. Do you agree or not?
Wow.
Talking about taking something I posted and turning it into something totally different.
Paranoia is alive and well on here.
no answer to my question then? You've had an irrational dislike of Hughes for some time, I just wonder if you may ever change your view of him as a manager.
levets said:no answer to my question then? You've had an irrational dislike of Hughes for some time, I just wonder if you may ever change your view of him as a manager.
No answer to your question, because I haven't said anything to suggest that I thought he should be judged on anything but performances.
Just that Bellamy cost more than £8.2m. Really not sure why you've felt the need to interpret my comments beyond that.
mammutly
Well-Known Member
It seems to me that in this context 'irrational' is a word that is used completely irrationally.
To question the ability of the manager is not 'irrational.' To dismiss any such question out of hand is what's really irrational.
To question the ability of the manager is not 'irrational.' To dismiss any such question out of hand is what's really irrational.
Kirkstall Blue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 22 Dec 2008
- Messages
- 6,495
- Location
- St Helens. Formally Manchester
- Team supported
- Manchester City
We are doing well so far this season winning away which is great, but!!
Did we question the ability of our previous managers to the same extent on Bluemoon???? as I didn't find this forum untill I thought we were going to sell Ireland and others.
Somehow a rational discussion with regard to tactic's and the present managers ability is greeted with accusations of ("it's because he is a rag legend") that you hold those views and if you don't share, the complete faith in him that some posters have then your not a blue.
If I had posted on here before MH. I'd have had plenty to say about Sven, Pearce and Keegans tactics.
Did we question the ability of our previous managers to the same extent on Bluemoon???? as I didn't find this forum untill I thought we were going to sell Ireland and others.
Somehow a rational discussion with regard to tactic's and the present managers ability is greeted with accusations of ("it's because he is a rag legend") that you hold those views and if you don't share, the complete faith in him that some posters have then your not a blue.
If I had posted on here before MH. I'd have had plenty to say about Sven, Pearce and Keegans tactics.
mammutly said:It seems to me that in this context 'irrational' is a word that is used completely irrationally.
To question the ability of the manager is not 'irrational.' To dismiss any such question out of hand is what's really irrational.
Oh dear.... way over your head. I too have questioned his ability at times. So not 'dismissed out of hand'
However this poster has had a negative view of Hughes since day one and never misses the opportunity to highlight this, despite him (Hughes) currently perfoming in his role. That is irrational!
mammutly
Well-Known Member
levets said:mammutly said:It seems to me that in this context 'irrational' is a word that is used completely irrationally.
To question the ability of the manager is not 'irrational.' To dismiss any such question out of hand is what's really irrational.
Oh dear.... way over your head. I too have questioned his ability at times. So not 'dismissed out of hand'
However this poster has had a negative view of Hughes since day one and never misses the opportunity to highlight this, despite him (Hughes) currently perfoming in his role. That is irrational!
I doubt you could ever go over my head ;-)
You have a different view. That's fine. I don't agree. Moomba might be a lot of things, but 'irrational' isn't one of them
levets said:However this poster has had a negative view of Hughes since day one and never misses the opportunity to highlight this, despite him (Hughes) currently perfoming in his role. That is irrational!
Err... I said Bellamy cost more than £8.2m, and used a quote from your man himself to confirm that is the case. Thats not exactly highlighting a negative view of anyone as fas as I can see.
Paranoia, paranoia, everybodies coming to get you.