BlueJill said:
Cobwebcat said:
So right and then wrong about part one and then wrong about part two. Not great is it?
Nearly ALL ITK knowledge is subject to change. That's the way it works. Things change. Tolmie has said that Sanchez was all but ours. Now the media is saying we have given up on him. Who knows if we really have or not. But if he does in fact go elsewhere does that mean Tolmie's info was wrong? If ITK's have to wait until the ink is in fact dry then there wouldn't be a need for them; we would just have to check the OS every day.
I agree with that up to a point but likewise if an ITK is correct then he has passed on info that was ITK and is lauded but if he was wrong then well "things change" so by that criteria everyone could be ITK as you could never lose.
Occasionally things happen that the press hasn't got hold of and they turn out to be correct. Very particular things like Stuart Taylor signing and he did. A person that posts such info obviously knows what he is talking about and can be forgiven a "things change" sceanario in the future because of course they do.
However, I'm not aware that Bombo has ever done this (as I've seen Tolmie do occasionaly between his youtube madness!) so I have to think maybe he knows no more than I do.
The imfamous Desert Rat (one post and gone) and Spursmad would also fall into this category who have proven they know stuff but can't be expected to get everything correct.