Is our cycle of dominance coming to an end?

We have dominated domestic football for the last 10 years but history always tells us that football is cyclical.

Our dominance was predominantly built on a core of Kompany, Toure, Silva, Aguero (and Fernandinho). All of them had/have true leadership, determination and left such an incredible mark on our club they have been and will be extremely difficult to replace.

Since then we’ve never signed the real world class player, but instead have trained potential up to being world class. Hence our model is built on players coming in with the right mentality, with a point to prove and supplementing our main men.

Eventually that model misses the target on recruitment or you lack enough leaders in the dressing room such that those with potential don’t live up to the hype.

With potentially all of the above gone by the end of this season, who is going to step up.
We now have a vacuum of vocal/physical leaders in the dressing room that is more important now than adding quality.

Without them we become weak (Arsenal, Chelsea and United have shown this in recent years) and without them we struggle to attract the superstar again without paying the big wages we did at the start.

We are at a critical time in our recent history, where we are still living off the foundations built by the players at the top. But soon as they are gone, who is there to carry the burden.

KDB will be one.
But after that we need a CB, a CDM and a ST all that dominate where we currently have none (once aguero is gone).

You can win cups with good players that deliver in the moment, but you will not dominate for an extended period without a spine of leaders. And currently we are miles off that.

Serious question, I would love to know who you consider to be World Class players we could have bought? and also why you don't think KDB was World Class when we bought him, myself and many others knew he was World Class, along with a few others we have purchased. You not class Ederson, Bernardo Silva and Laporte as World Class?
 
It's easier to work towards a goal, than maintain the heights someone else has set. Lose on the way up and it's a learning curve and inspires you to not lose again, lose at the top and it's a let down and breaks that invincible feeling and affects confidence.

p.s leaving Joe Hart out of the OP, Sweet Baby Jesus and the orphans, mind me juices, unforgivable :)
 
City's main problem is bringing in players in who can actually IMPROVE the team , and not players who will merely 'make do', because that's what's REALLY makes the difference ..... in my opinion the jury is still out on a young Ferran Torres .... Ake is merely an average defender from a pityful poor relegated side, and if we bring in that carthorse, Koulibaly, from what i've seen of him he's hardly likely to improve us either ..... so unless Guardiola wakes up a bit and at AT LEAST gets this defence right , he's gonna be chasing Klopp for another season or two , if not more!

We may well have conceded only TWO more goals than Liverpool, but how we managed that is a bit of a mystery, when we actually conceded so many chances to the opposition ...... we totally outscored Liverpool in the league fixtures , but they won the title because their impressive defence simply just didn't concede goals in as MANY games as we did, allowing them to 'steal' wins , often by very the narrowest of margins !
 
Last edited:
Serious question, I would love to know who you consider to be World Class players we could have bought? and also why you don't think KDB was World Class when we bought him, myself and many others knew he was World Class, along with a few others we have purchased. You not class Ederson, Bernardo Silva and Laporte as World Class?

I wouldnt say any of them were world class at the time of purchase no.
They had potential but none of them were starters for any team in the world at that time.
 
Its a good point you Make.
We maybe havent dominated but we have been the best and most consistant team in the past decade.
Will we be as dominant and consistant over the next five years... ??
The competition is getting stronger and we have some great players coming to their end.
but.
i trust we will make more great signings.

The one thing that is certain is - we will challenge for honours again every year in the 20s.
We are here to stay.
getting bigger getting stronger getting better
CTID
 
Every heard of ‘typical city’ or ‘cityitis’ mate?
Or does other fans opinions not count if its not the same as yours.
Im being realistic

Im not expectant of sweeping anything. Im just saying I fully expect a challenging season, one we havent had for a while, based on where we stand now. Hopefully we perform and we do well again.

But I do not expect, if the same continues, to be anywhere near as dominant as we have been and we could easily fall below several teams such is what the prem is like.

Trying to gauge opinion and what anyone else thinks we need to do, longer term. But if you want to stick your head in the sand and tell yourself everything will be alright, be my guest.
What. The. Actual. Fuck.
 
We have dominated domestic football for the last 10 years but history always tells us that football is cyclical.

Our dominance was predominantly built on a core of Kompany, Toure, Silva, Aguero (and Fernandinho). All of them had/have true leadership, determination and left such an incredible mark on our club they have been and will be extremely difficult to replace.

Since then we’ve never signed the real world class player, but instead have trained potential up to being world class. Hence our model is built on players coming in with the right mentality, with a point to prove and supplementing our main men.

Eventually that model misses the target on recruitment or you lack enough leaders in the dressing room such that those with potential don’t live up to the hype.

With potentially all of the above gone by the end of this season, who is going to step up.
We now have a vacuum of vocal/physical leaders in the dressing room that is more important now than adding quality.

Without them we become weak (Arsenal, Chelsea and United have shown this in recent years) and without them we struggle to attract the superstar again without paying the big wages we did at the start.

We are at a critical time in our recent history, where we are still living off the foundations built by the players at the top. But soon as they are gone, who is there to carry the burden.

KDB will be one.
But after that we need a CB, a CDM and a ST all that dominate where we currently have none (once aguero is gone).

You can win cups with good players that deliver in the moment, but you will not dominate for an extended period without a spine of leaders. And currently we are miles off that.
I don't think we will see 100 points again but as long as our ownership remains intact we will always be competing for honours at the highest level. That is all I have ever wanted as a City fan. Football is boring when one team dominates all the time.
 
I think every time we made a clear gap between City and the pack we sat on it and let them catch up by not continuing to build or replace the quality we had. FFP obviously played a part .
Liverpool,Chelsea,Arsenal & Raggies are all at or close to us.
If our dominance has waned then it was nice while it lasted but could and should have lasted longer.
 
I don't think we will see 100 points again but as long as our ownership remains intact we will always be competing for honours at the highest level. That is all I have ever wanted as a City fan. Football is boring when one team dominates all the time.
I remember all the Rags remarking on this all through the 90's and the first decade of the Noughties...like fuck i did, dirty bastards.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.