Is Rooney the new Alan Smith?

[Sky Blue]

He still shows touches of quality. His ball to berbatov for the first goal was good and his chip was good too. The worrying thing for me is that they are still top with only one goal from him

Have a minute off from worrying.....

 

[ono]

Nah Smith was never any good.

 

[fbloke]

At least Roonster can say he had a decent World Cup and won the Golden Boot.............

 

[City Raider]

if plug or vid get a long term injury, they will stuggle

 

[tweety]

He sucked the devil's cock

 

[Sparkys-Army]

Slight difference, I like Alan Smith.

I would go as far as saying Alan and Shauny were my idols when i was kid. This led to me have a soft spot for leds currently but shaun was the man who gave me my love for Man City :)

<3

 

[Balti]

he is the worlds greatest player and England's world cup saviour

he is not at all over-rated and would look really great in The Shirt

[cough]

 

[svennis pennis]

Played an incredible 50 yard pass today apparently.

 

[Ric]

As loathe as I am to say it, anyone writing off Rooney is either being very optimistic or very naive. The comparisons to Smith suugest the latter. Thankfully he's been utterly mediocre so far this season, but you don't become a bad player overnight.

 

[Fame Monster]

Over-rated but still better than Smith.