It's Quiet thread 14 - 'do one' edition

[Centurions]

I agree with that but Allison/Ederson is debatable and I’d have Sterling over Salah. Maybe Foden or Bernardo would get in too.

Presuming you're talking about playing the City way then there is no debate whatsoever about Eddie or Alison, it's Eddie all day long. In fact you could include every goalie in the world in the debate and there still would be no debate.

 

[Neville Kneville]

You wouldn't want Liverpool's fullbacks defending in our team or our fullbacks crossing in theirs.

We wouldn't especially want any of their midfield in our team. Several of ours would be able to play in theirs.

Aguero, fully fit is the best striker in the league.

But any comparisons made, should be looked at if Van Dijk spent months injured.

Then, I doubt many people would be envious of Liverpool players in general.

 

[OrigamiNinja]

He's good going forward, not so much defensively. I prefer Walker and wouldn't swap them.

Walker makes more cock-ups than TAA. People talk like Walkers defensive qualities are up there with VVD. Myth. I worry about the mental well-being of anyone on here who would take Walker over TAA.

At the moment only Laporte, KDB and Aguero definitely get in the Liverpool side. There are a few (Bernardo, Foden, Ederson) at their best would potentially get in there.

 

[Jazzman]

Liverpool's players look good because Klopp have a system that allows them to play to their strengths thus masking weaknesses. They would not look as good in other setups.

 

[alexmcity]

Generally, comparisons between first XIs tend to be daft, because much depends on tactics and the managers. For instance, Fabinho, who was crap for many months anyway after he got injured last December and cost Liverpool in the CL, is not a Pep player for his percentage of completed passes is not sufficiently high. Further, we don't need FBs to be our top assistants, we score 100 goals anyway.

How many Liverpool players are guaranteed to start for City under Pep? VVD, Robertson and Salah, given that Sterling plays on the left now. Even if you add TAA, that makes 4 players.

 

[wolviedinho]

You wouldn't want Liverpool's fullbacks defending in our team or our fullbacks crossing in theirs.

We wouldn't especially want any of their midfield in our team. Several of ours would be able to play in theirs.

Aguero, fully fit is the best striker in the league.

But any comparisons made, should be looked at if Van Dijk spent months injured.

Then, I doubt many people would be envious of Liverpool players in general.

We won’t know how they would of handled the loss of van dijk or say mane and sala at the same time. I would imagine they would of struggled.

They have a very good team and luck and Var is all behind them. Liverpool = good and MCFC =bad. The American have always been good at winning the propaganda war.

The only real difference between us and them is efficiently. They are lethal and ruthless in front of goal and we are not.

 

[come-on-barney]

He will not likely feature now that City have considerable depth at CB, no logic to play a player who wants to leave as a result

No idea how his performances were noticably worse since Pep announced he was off when we already know the 1st half against Leicester he was arguably the best player on the pitch.

Pity football matches were only one half.

 

[Sky Blue]

Sterling is back to doing my head in.

By scoring goals ?

 

[Benarbia’s Backheel]

Presuming you're talking about playing the City way then there is no debate whatsoever about Eddie or Alison, it's Eddie all day long. In fact you could include every goalie in the world in the debate and there still would be no debate.

Even though he’s an average shot stopper?

 

[not my fault!]

It’s a slow day when we are talking about other teams players... Their fans must be pissing their sides reading this lol.