It's Quiet Thread 15 - Txiki Blinders

Status
Not open for further replies.
simon23 said:
See something else i posted on this...cant be bothered to repost it but its more comprehensive (though along the same lines)
Click to expand...

I've seen it.

Firstly, the graphic is wrong. Aguero hasn't got 54 PL goals against the Big 6. It's actually 44 and you can confirm that from the other full stats you posted.

Secondly, the full stats also back up my post which was as follows and is accurate:

Best ratio of goals per PL appearance against:


Arsenal – Kane
Chelsea – Aguero
Liverpool – Kane
United – Aguero

Everton – Kane
Leicester – Kane
Southampton – Kane
West Ham – Kane

But Aguero far better ratio against Spurs than Kane v City.
-------------------

The bottom line is his record against the better sides in the PL is excellent

The point is IMO is no one on here including me will think Kane>Aguero, but Kane has consistently produced a big volume of PL goals for the last 7 seasons at an average of 23 per season. He is a machine FFS. And that consistency suggests he is highly likely to continue being a machine.
 
Last edited:
simon23 said:
why do we have to have a proven PL striker? But if you want a list Id have Salah, Vardy and Mane over Kane for starters....Haaland, Dybala, Lewandowski at least from outside the prem areothers that id have over him....Kane is not the be all and end all and neither is the prem league.

The comparrison between Sergio and Kane is very relevant as its Sergio we are trying to replace....so it cant be more relevant.

However Id take a fit and firing Aguero even at his age over Kane (problem being his fitness - Agueros that is - though there seems to be some suggestion in some places that Agueros lack of appearnaces last season wasnt just down to a lack of fitness or at least that he may have been available more than suggested (though that could be bullshit of course)
And Im not sure why you are saying that they are two different type of players...every player is different but in terms of role in the team (striker) they are the same
Click to expand...
Dybala?
You must hate Kane so much you have become detached from reality
He’s scored 20 league goals in three years.
Kane will have that by Christmas this season!
 
tolmie's hairdoo said:
Are you okay mate, you seen to be going in off the deep end?

You have Vardy and Dybala as preferential to Harry Kane, on course to break even Alan Shearer's record.

A Vardy who is finished, lost all his pace over the last 16 months and has repeated groin and hamstring problems as a result of his downturn.

Dybala? An overhyped stump, seemingly so good that he has been heading for the exit at Juve every summer for the last five years?

City not being impacted by Covid last season, thus being able to take advantage over the rest of the league.

City seemingly only winning at Anfield last season because they had no fans, choosing to give zero credit to a team that was already motoring their way to 25 wins on the bounce in all comps?

Just read that back, because all your arguments are based simply on what might be, could be, what you think happened.

Not trying to be disrespectful, but a lot of what you have stated is disrespectful to not only City, but players who exist in a different postcode to some of those statements.

And I include Kane in that. A scoring machine in a team that isn't even in the same galaxy as City in terms of the chances it creates.

Kane doesn't have to be Haaland, he just needs to be Kane.

That will ensure we stay on top.
Click to expand...

Simon is at least consistent. He was adamant that Walker was a bang average waste of money who was being sold by Spurs at a rip off rate because Poch had figured out he couldn't play two games a week. Similar sentiments now being echoed about Kane.
 
BillyShears said:
Simon is at least consistent. He was adamant that Walker was a bang average waste of money who was being sold by Spurs at a rip off rate because Poch had figured out he couldn't play two games a week. Similar sentiments now being echoed about Kane.
Click to expand...
Let’s hope end result is similar
Walker is as good as ever now
 
p.taker said:
OrnateDependableLeafbird-max-1mb.gif
Click to expand...
We're talking about Haaland not Kane
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.