It's Quiet Thread 15 - Txiki Blinders

[samuelyeboah]

Ffs why do people think they know better than the people running our club that brought us sustained success over the last 11 years??? To call the transfer window a severe fuck up for only breaking the British transfer record on a world class player is baffling

because we're not sheeple and we're able to discern when something OBVIOUSLY doesn't go to plan?

Plus, having signed grealish doesn't make not getting a strike not a fuck-up??? if you signed jan oblak for 100m would you say that was a successful window? No because you didn't solve the (admittedly not that big) holes in your squad and instead strengthened an already strong position. Getting grealish is the definition of icing on the cake but we forgot to get the cake this window.

 

[Deleted member 87819]

Doesn’t make us weaker and we are stronger, and until teams play we have no idea whether they are stronger, making big signings doesn't always make a team stronger. Sometimes it makes them worse.

Of course a team can sign many players and it not work, but to hope that it will happen with all the teams that strengthened is a tougher ask

 

[samuelyeboah]

You are confusing signing a striker and strengthening the squad.

If you just accept we play without a striker, and instead play with a front 5 who can largely interchange, its pretty obvious that adding a £100m player like Grealish (who was one of the best players in the league last year.) Is strengthening the side.

You can put our front 5 of Sterling, Grealish, Foden, Mahrez, Torres, KDB and Gundogan up against the attack of anyone in the league and it will score more goals.

but even your manager doesn't "accept" that or he wouldn't have chased 2 world class strikers this window, come on

 

[domalino]

Because he came first?!

Yes.

Because Pep and Khaldoon and Txiki sat down and worked out a budget of how much we could spend this season, and Pep told them to sign Grealish for £100m even though it mean they didn't have enough for Kane after.

 

[samuelyeboah]

I think people are confusing "are you happy with the squad and think we are stronger this season", which to me the answer is unequivocally YES, and "do you think we fucked up this transfer window", which the answer is also yes. both of these can be true!

Yes.

Because Pep and Khaldoon and Txiki sat down and worked out a budget of how much we could spend this season, and Pep told them to sign Grealish for £100m even though it mean they didn't have enough for Kane after.

that is pure speculation from you.

 

[Deleted member 87819]

What have what our rivals got to do with our squad being weaker or stronger?

Forget what anyone else has done, is our squad, player for player, weaker or stronger this season?

You have to look around. You might have the fastest car in the block and get an even faster car the next year, but you also have to look at the cars the others got to know if it’s still the fastest

 

[domalino]

but even your manager doesn't "accept" that or he wouldn't have chased 2 world class strikers this window, come on

He does accept it or he could sign any of 100 strikers in Europe.

He tried to sign 1 world class striker who's build up play was good enough to fit in with the rest of the front 5, and he half heartedly went after a goalscoring winger.

Ronaldo is not a striker. He has never played as a striker, not at United, Real and definitely not at Juventus.

 

[Gumzy97]

 

[Maly]

Maybe we'd have conjured up more than 1 shot..

So if we only had one shot, surely our creative players didn’t create enough for any striker to have more than one shot no?

Maybe a striker would’ve made a difference, but it’s certainly not as black & white as you were staying with the FA Cup & CL comment pal

 

[Cityinmud]

Another one. Instead of whining about no back up plan name some credible targets. I'll wait.

Our club was ready to sign a 36 year old ronaldo as an emergency option because they didn't have a plan B prepared. Here are strikers better than ronaldo. Martinez, dusan, felix, andre silva to name a few.